Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Improperty Tax

[After so many letters to ease up on property tax, here's one who's going after the big landed property owners.]

Feb 16, 2011
Make property tax more equitable

ACCORDING to Saturday's report ("Housing affordability of key concern"), the general sentiment is that the Government would be dishing out property, utility and service and conservancy rebates, upgrading old estates to increase the supply of HDB flats and providing larger housing grants for lower-income households in this year's Budget.
While these measures would be welcomed, they are just stop-gap measures and do not address the root of the problem: land scarcity in Singapore.

Land scarcity inevitably leads to high property prices as the supply of properties is insufficient to meet demand. Living in landed property is definitely a luxury and to ensure efficient and equitable allocation of resources, luxuries should be priced accordingly to reflect their scarcity. The current property tax policy in Singapore does not adhere to this principle of efficient allocation.

Currently, properties are taxed based on their annual value, which is the estimated amount of rental the properties would fetch if they were to be rented out. At first glance, one might be convinced that the landed property owner is paying a higher property tax and is thus paying a fair price for his luxury. However, the current tax rates fail to separate the concept of property from land.

Take, for example, a bungalow that sits on a 10,000 sq m plot of land could accommodate 40 three-room flats. Thus we can say that for the same size of land, HDB flat dwellers collectively pay a higher amount of tax than a landed property dweller.

Furthermore, the tax places a bigger financial burden on the lower-income group.

A property tax reform where the notions of land and property are separated is due. Property owners should still be taxed based on the estimated rental revenue, but at a lower rate. The balance should come from a land tax, where property owners are taxed based on the size of the plot they occupy and also the share of the plot which they occupy. Thus, the landed property owner would pay tax for the whole of his bungalow, while an HDB flat dweller living in a 20-storey block would pay 1/20 of the land tax. This new tax regime would be more equitable.

Goh Ching Soon

[Amazing how ingenious Singaporeans can be when it comes to shifting their tax burdens onto other people. Yeah, let's stick it to the land owners! We'll make him pay tax for imaginary, yet to be built flats.

Oh and you live in a 20 story flat? Haven't you heard? Duxton Plain is now 40 stories high. Oh but since we are going for imaginary, I think I can imagine a time when we will have 70 or even 100 storey flats. You are squatting on a scarce resource! You in your underdeveloped 20 storey only flat!

We should just put you and with the other property tax reformers in a steel cage and let you all sort it out.]


Feb 9, 2011
Why Iras should review formula for property tax

MR PAUL Chan ('Adopt fairer tax system for owner-occupiers'; Jan 23) is right in advocating a new and fairer formula for property tax.

The current method of tagging market value to rental value is grossly unfair to owner-occupiers, and my personal experience is a good example.

When we experienced the worst year of economic growth in 2009, the property tax went down by only 23.5 per cent from that in the preceding, pre-crisis year.

[That was the year there was a 40% property tax rebate. It was a once off.]

Yet the same tax shot up by a whopping 98 per cent last year, which meant the property tax paid in 2010 was 50 per cent higher than that in the 2008 pre-crisis year.

And the economy has not even recovered to pre-crisis levels.

There were also four adjustments made between 2007 and last year, three of which were increases and one, a decrease.

Is there a need for such frequent adjustments in tax rates?

All the above reinforces the view that when times are bad, the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (Iras) returns less than it should, but when times are good, it takes back a lot more than it deserves.

The efforts by Iras to introduce adjustments and inform taxpayers could have been saved if a different formula is used.

As an owner-occupier, I do not lose or benefit from economic changes or changes in rental value, so why is my property tax not reflecting that?

Thian Tai Chew

[As an owner-occupier, you pay concessionary property tax. That is a recognition that you are not overtly gaining economically from the property. But your property is an asset and has economic value. If not to you, to others. A home in a more central area has a higher value. It means you have more amenities and conveniences. Someone living in a less central area has less conveniences and probably incurs more costs to enjoy the same conveniences and amenities.]

Monday, February 14, 2011

CHARITY LEADERS' SALARIES

Feb 14, 2011

If you pay peanuts, you get...

MR VICTOR Looi's letter ('Avoid paying big salaries to hire charity leaders'; last Friday) raises the issue of what really constitutes hefty pay.

Having served as a volunteer of local charity Make-A-Wish Singapore since its inception and board chairman since 2007, and being a past chairman of Make-A-Wish Foundation International, I have been involved in many discussions on this issue of CEO remuneration and benefits.

The argument that charity leaders should not be motivated by financial benefits is a lofty ideal, but is it realistic in today's society, and what is fair and reasonable compensation?

Let us look at the principal duties and responsibilities of a charity chief executive:
  • Ensure that the charity mission is carried out well and meets the needs of its beneficiaries;

  • Ensure the highest standards of governance within the organisation, so as to comply with the strict code of governance for charities;

  • Initiate and implement fund-raising and financial stewardship programmes so that there are sufficient funds;

  • Inspire and organise volunteers;

  • Maintain relations with the community and media; and

  • Manage office staff, oversee human resource policies and serve as a link between board members and office staff.
Such a multi-faceted and multi-tasking individual, with great many responsibilities, also needs to have the warm, engaging personality expected of a charity leader.

Such a person is not easily found, even in the highest echelons of for-profit organisations or multinational corporations.

A recent survey of CEO compensation for 2008-2009 by ASAE - The Centre for Association Leadership, an organisation representing more than 11,000 trade associations and voluntary organisations in 50 countries, indicated that for an organisation with an annual budget of US$1 million (S$1.3million) to US$2.5 million, the average annual salary for CEOs is between US$134,000 and US$154,000.

Is this applicable as a benchmark for Singapore? For a First World country, with a cost of living, gross domestic product and property prices among the highest in Asia, these figures are surely something for us to ponder.

Furthermore, if we apply the same argument that ministers, who give up lucrative careers in the private sector for the higher calling of serving the nation, should be fairly and reasonably compensated for their sacrifice, then we need to change our mindset about the salaries of our charity leaders.

As the oft-repeated saying goes: 'If you pay peanuts, you get...'


Dr Keith Goh

Online comments

Paying peanuts you get monkeys do carry some weight however, what assurances has the public got (don't forget the NKF Saga), despite all the governance in place the CEO still manages to get away for some time?If $$$$$ issue is a key factor, I would appeal the "gorillas" to stay out of it as to be involved in charity starts off with CHARITY above everything else.
Posted by: yklim008 at Mon Feb 14 15:05:01 SGT 2011

i don't ask for a lot when i know i'm performing charity, just a token, and even that may seem like a lot to the poor. it's my way of giving back. but i have little sympathy shall we say, when i'm dealing with someone who can afford to pay. they don't need my charity. they're looking for an experience and i deliver just that.
Posted by: unewolke at Mon Feb 14 14:14:27 SGT 2011

i see that people are motivated by money/greed, some more so than others. that is fine, but don't work in a charity if you don't want to give more than take. i've been on both sides - earning a little or a lot based on the same skill sets.
Posted by: unewolke at Mon Feb 14 14:13:37 SGT 2011

[Social workers also have family commitments and bills to pay. They may have the aptitude to work with disadvantaged people, but they also need to be properly compensated for their time and their education. The problem is that most people seem to think that Charity work is volunteer work. Yes. There are volunteers, but when the problem is dealing with family issues, financial problems, gambling, drinking, addiction, unemployment, discipline, delinquency, parenting and other complex socio-psychological issues, volunteers are out of their depth. You need social workers trained and resourced to help these individuals and their families with their specific problems.

And these social workers need to be paid adequately.

And the administrators and executives who help and support these social workers may have good intentions, but they also bills to pay and a family to feed. Helping the poor does not mean they have to be as poor as the people they help.

If we continue to pay them pittance, they we attract the low talent, no-talent, and failures. They have limited competence and they cannot make the charity strong and viable. And the charity fails. Look at the social work charities. Most of them are poorly run. Many are living from hand to mouth, disaster and failure just one donation away. And social workers are making sacrifices in terms of salaries. They can continue for some time, but eventually, they will burn out, or decide that they need to look after themselves and they leave the sector taking with them a wealth of experience. And the social sector is poorer for the loss of these experienced social workers.]

Monday, February 7, 2011

What it is like to be a mum in Finland

Feb 7, 2011

I AM a Singaporean mother who is currently on maternity leave in Finland ('Encourage gender equality and the babies will come'; Jan 22). I was holding a job there - technically, I still do - when my child came along.

A month before my expected delivery date, I started my maternity leave. For the next eight months, I would receive up to 80 per cent of my salary with two full months paid for by the company and the rest covered by the state.

After that, should I choose to stay at home with my baby in his formative years, my position in the company would be held for up to three years. A child allowance of €200 (S$350) is also paid monthly until the child grows well into his teens.

Family-friendly benefits are by no means restricted to mothers. Fathers are given up to three weeks of paternity leave. And because they are expected to chip in with child rearing, a certain portion of benefits can be shared by the father if he stays at home while the mother returns to work.

Benefits in Finland are classed as maternity and parental allowances to reflect the equally important role of fathers in bringing up a child.

Singapore has come a long way to join the First World club but like its counterparts, it is also afflicted with the bane of falling birth rates. Singapore's policymakers must weigh the pro-business policies that keep the cost of labour low and make Singapore competitive, against the cost of creating an environment where the burden of having a baby does not fall squarely on the mother's shoulder.

A paradigm shift in people's mindset is also needed so that women are not discriminated against in the workplace and men play a bigger role in parenting.

Ashley Chang (Ms)



[Benefits have to be paid for in some way. There is no mention of taxes in Finland. The tax is 6.5% to 30%, with municipal tax of 15% - 20%. Corporate tax is another 26%.

In contrast, Singapore taxes are 3.5% to 20% personal income tax, with 7% GST, and 17% corporate tax.

The paradigm shift may well need a tax system shift.]

Sunday, February 6, 2011

The day it was raining money at Sentosa...

Feb 7, 2011

MY FAMILY and I were at the Universal Studios at Sentosa around midday last Friday. I was waiting underneath the roller coaster Battlestar Galactica which my overjoyed children were riding as it intermittently opened to the public for test runs.
Imagine my surprise when it suddenly started raining money - mostly Malaysian ringgit. Imagine my greater surprise when the crowd of people around me did not make a rush for it. Instead of filling their pockets and walking away congratulating themselves on their good fortune, strangers belonging to various races and nationalities organised themselves to pick up the money which was lying on the ground.
They found a wallet bulging with cash, a RM1,000 clip of 20 RM50 notes as well as an assortment of other notes - altogether not an insignificant sum. They then located a staff member and handed over the money and wallet to him.
A few minutes later, a family of six tourists emerged from the exit. They were distraught, fully expecting the money to be lost. The mother could be heard loudly berating her son for being so stupid as to drop the family's money packet.
But the family was in for a pleasant surprise. Without any fuss, the staff member approached them, confirmed their identity using the identity card found in the wallet and returned the money.
It was a wonderful display of honesty, integrity and decency by a group of ordinary Singaporeans and visitors that day.
Andrew Ong

[Thank you, Andrew Ong for sharing this.]

Thursday, January 27, 2011

All for a strong Singdollar

Jan 28, 2011

ACCORDING to the Monetary Authority of Singapore's (MAS) website, our total official foreign reserves have ballooned by more than 94 per cent from US$116 billion in 2005 to about US$226 billion (S$289 billion) last year.
This may look good to most people, but I see it as a dramatic intervention by MAS to weaken the real value of the Singdollar over a short span of five years by buying up freshly printed money of foreign governments.
I prefer a strong Singdollar. Whenever a foreign government debases its currency, it affects our foreign reserve holding. At best, a large forex reserve gives our government a lot more money and enables our exporters to sell into markets chronically stricken with trade deficits. However, these are not necessarily a good thing.
A realistically strong Singdollar allows better distribution of wealth as it does not dilute the savings and earnings of Singaporeans. It keeps interest rates realistic, higher than the current Singapore Interbank Offered Rate which is near zero, and dampens speculation and over-borrowing. This keeps real inflation down and housing prices affordable. It also encourages saving and spending within one's means.
I suggest MAS sell off some foreign reserves for tangibles such as gold and silver, and allow the Singdollar to strengthen naturally. Stop subsidising the currencies of nations with chronic trade deficits at the expense of the Singdollar.
Our export sectors can benefit from significantly lower imported input costs and still remain internationally competitive.
Yong Jianjun

[First of all, just because the value of the foreign reserves is totalled and valued in US$, doesn't mean that it IS held all and only as US$. Most country hold a basket of foreign currency including gold.
Second, currencies that are considered as foreign reserves are not so easily "debased". The US$ can fall over time, and it has because it has been printing money to finance its debt, but it is still holding its value.
Third, foreign reserves may be used to defend a country's forex rate, but it is not the sole determinant of the strength and stability of the S$.
Fourth, on what basis do you say that our export sectors can benefit significantly from lower import costs and still remain competitive internationally? What figures do you have to support that conclusion? A rising S$ would mean our exports will be less competitive to the EU, China, Malaysia and US. It is for the same reason China is keeping its yuan low and buying US$ and US debt. Is this sustainable? Maybe not. Alternatives? No easy answer.
Finally, buying and holding gold is not the best answer. If it is, every country would only hold gold as reserves. Why don't they?]

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Economic link to falling fertility rates

Jan 27, 2011

I AGREE with Ms Laurelle He ('Encourage gender equality and the babies will come'; last Saturday). In Sweden, if parents care jointly for the child, they are entitled to 240 days' leave each with parental benefit. Monthly child allowance of 1,050 Swedish kronor (S$205) per child is also paid up to and including the quarter when the child reaches the age of 16.
If Singapore makes a paradigm shift and matches the Swedish family benefits, I am sure Singaporeans could do much better.
Our declining birth rate was largely due to social and economic transformation during the last 50 years, when more women with better education joined the workforce. Materialism and pragmatism have forced child-bearing to take a backseat. The trend seems irreversible due to changing perceptions.
I did a cursory comparison of Singapore's TFR to its gross domestic product (GDP) over the last 60 years, and found our TFR to be inversely proportional to our GDP.Until we change the economic model to be more family-friendly, the falling birth rate may slide further.
Paul Chan

[Wow! Amazing! Stop the press! Economic development is inversely proportional to TFR!

Big Fat hairy Deal.

So? The solution is to reduce economic growth until we have unemployment, poverty, barely enough to eat, no money for entertainment, can't afford TV and sex is our only recreation, then produce more children?

Why don't you do a correlation between infant mortality rate and TFR. Inversely proportional also right? So does that mean we should cut down on post-natal and infant care, increase infant mortality, and so people would produce more children as insurance against losing some of them?

Or do a correlation between education and TFR or education level of women and TFR. The more education you put in a woman the less babies come out right? So? Ban education for women?

The GDP - TFR link is a correlation not causation unless a clear hypothesis as to causation can be tested and proven/disproved.

The problem of the TFR is a complex issue. The question is not should we have strong economic growth or more children. The question should be how do we have more children while sustaining our economic growth.

There does not seem to be any simple solution. Feedback cannot totally be trusted as people use this issue to blackmail the government - give me a flat, a maid, COE/Car, maternity leave, paternity leave, childcare leave, subsidy, priority, medical, career guarantee, etc THEN I will have more babies.

Simplistic answers with meaningless stats are not helpful.]

Saturday, January 22, 2011

'Reason enough to revisit polygamy?'


DR GORDON TAN: 'As a gynaecologist who helps sub-fertile couples conceive, I have seen many couples who put off childbearing as they are busy working to pay off their housing and car loans ('Time for stork-taking on baby issue'; Tuesday). When they duly arrive financially, many husbands lament that even though they are now ready financially and socially for another child, their wives have become biologically too old for childbearing. Could there then be reason enough for us to revisit polygamy?'

[Dr Tan. I hope your wife tonight will ask you who you have in mind as your second wife. :-)

In any case, there are grandmothers who have children for their daughters, albeit via in-vitro fertilisation and other fertility procedures. So why do you automatically choose the polygyny option?

The other option is to use your sperm, your wife's egg (if still viable) or a donor egg, and a surrogate mother (if your wife is unable or unwilling to carry a pregancy).

In future, this might be the way forward. Rich older couples will pay a young woman to carry a pregnancy to term for them in exchange for cash payment, treatment to extract and freeze some of the young woman's eggs, and of course all expenses related to the cost of carrying the pregnancy to term. This will give the young woman some start-up cash for business or other enterprise. Then later when she is older and gets married, she can use her frozen eggs (from when she was younger), to be fertilised with her husband's sperm (or sperm of choice), and pay a younger woman to carry her child to term, for the same benefits.

And the cycle continues.

This solves the problem for the woman of choosing between career and biology. ]