Monday, March 14, 2011

Why S'pore should back Timor Leste

Mar 14, 2011
INCLUSION IN ASEAN

MR BARRY Wain highlighted how Indonesia is pushing for inclusion of Timor Leste in Asean while Singapore was cited as leading the objectors ('Timor Leste's bid to join Asean faces objections'; last Thursday).

It appears the main reason for excluding Timor Leste now is that its institutions and human capital are undeveloped and, therefore, cannot keep up with Asean's integration efforts, especially economically.

The worry, it seems, is that Asean must substantially integrate its economies by 2015, failing which it would be rendered irrelevant; a loser in the face of rising China and India. The newer, and generally poorer, Asean members like Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar are also worried about the likely diversion of aid if Timor Leste joins.

I take a different view. We should commend Indonesia and Thailand for supporting Timor Leste's inclusion, with few or no reservations. Timor Leste had a painful birth 12 years ago, after an angry Indonesia withdrew from then East Timor in an orgy of killing and destruction. Jakarta is now relenting and championing Timor Leste's inclusion.

Singapore also had a painful birth in 1965 when it was evicted from the young Malaysian federation, two years after joining it amid fanfare. In the 1960s and 1970s, we were a struggling island trying to be a nation. Many doubted Singapore would make it; there was a danger of a failed state. Then, we appreciated any help given to build Singapore and our human capital.
Asean's formation by Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore and Thailand was a blessing, ensuring security and stability in the previously tumultuous region after the colonial powers left. Singapore has prospered since then.

There is a parallel with Timor Leste's case. The small, former Portuguese colony is now at peace with itself, its people ready to learn and to advance the country. Given its beautiful landscapes and coral reefs, tourism is taking off while various industries are budding. It needs more help in developing transport, health care, education and financial services, and guidance on economic development and security.

Singapore, as a small successful state, should go out of its way to help Timor Leste stand more firmly on its feet on various fronts. Asean economic integration is important, but even more vital is the need to ensure that Timor Leste, located in the middle of the Indonesian archipelago, does not fail. Asean cannot be at peace with itself if this happens.

Mano Sabnani

[By all means help Timor Leste. But ASEAN membership with the accompanying obligations are not necessarily the best way to help Timor Leste.

Everyone in ASEAN is studying for their "A" levels and Timor Leste comes along graduating from kindergarten and wants to take the "A" levels with the rest? It will fail. The best thing for Timor Leste is to pass PSLE first. the ASEAN members can help by providing tuition, even as they focus on their "A" levels.

This letter just appeals to emotions. There was no ASEAN when Singapore was "born". It is only when Sg was stable and ready was ASEAN formed. Timor Leste can be helped but dragging them into ASEAN when they are not ready is just a show at best and political maneuvering by Indonesia and Thailand at worse, using Timor Leste as the patsy.]

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Proposed skywalk icon impractical, will be an eyesore

Mar 6, 2011
YOUR LETTERS

Mr Harry Tong ('Build 'skywalk' mall as national icon'; Feb20) proposed that Singapore consider building its next icon in the form of a 5km-long, three-storey-high, open-air skywalk pedestrian mall running above the existing Orchard/Bras Basah roads and stretching to the Marina Bay area.

Beyond the factors of feasibility and costs, there are at least three major issues with this proposal.

First, the idea of a skywalk as an above-ground connector between buildings emerged from the need to protect pedestrians from crime and inclement weather in certain North American cities.

[We have inclement weather here too. And floods too.]

Because of its original design intentions, the skywalk also drains pedestrian traffic from the street level, thereby impoverishing the existing street life without necessarily compensating for this loss, since pedestrians typically use the skywalk only to move between destinations.

[Have you seen Orchard Road? It can do with some draining (of pedestrians as well as rain water). In any case, window shoppers are not so dumb as to window shop on the streets. They go into Ion, wander thru to Wisma, then into Ngee Ann City/Takashimaya, pop out onto the street only because that is the only way to link to the next shopping mall. People on the street clearly want to move to their next destination anyway.]

If a skywalk is built here as proposed, it will impoverish the present vibrancy of street-level activities on Orchard Road without any certainty of recreating such activities again above ground.

Second, a skywalk on the scale of what Mr Tong proposed would be more of an urban travesty than a national icon. It will cast a shadow over everything below it.

Imagine the underside of such a long skywalk. It will be similar to the underside of a concrete highway. Can this serve as an attractive space for vibrant street life?

[Here I think there is some concern. A almost fully enclosed skywalk will lead to a build up of vehicle exhaust which would potentially make the "Underwalk" a health hazard. But this need not be so, with proper ventilation and eventually if/when we switch to more electric vehicles. And the unimaginative concrete tunnel is the brainchild of an unimaginative brain.]

Third, the need to rely on yet another icon to attract more tourist dollars is unsettling.

'Icon' means the representation or imagery of some identity - an icon is thus not the real thing. To rely continuously on different representations to sell Singapore to the world undermines the commitment to the kind of social solidarity, and hence civic identity, that iconic representations cannot offer but which every unique city or state integrally requires.

[LKY is iconic. We should tell him he is not coke, i.e. not the real thing. I don't even know what this point is about. Probably an iconic rant with no real substance. Probably taking a word out of context, and arguing semantics. Yeah, I'm sure every tourists to Singapore is here to see our civic identity. We should charge admission for it.]


For these reasons, the proposal for yet another eye-catching icon, whether in the form of a skywalk or some other urban structure, needs to be considered carefully.

Jeffrey Chan

[Get off your high horse and walk. If you like high horses, you might like the skywalk.]

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Don't miss the fishes for the shark's fin

Mar 4, 2011

MANY marine conservation groups profess to champion the concept of sustainable seafood but actually focus primarily on the issue of shark's fin ('Shark's fin: Marine group rebuts trader's claim' by Project: FIN; March 1).
The shark is only one among millions of fish species in the seas and oceans. Granted, the number of sharks has declined but the same goes for all other commercial species.
Researchers have logged the decline in sharks, but how does that relate to the decline in the total fish population?
If the fish population declines by 90 per cent, does it not follow that the shark population will drop as well?
A report last year ('Overfishing emptying the seas in South-east Asia'; Nov11) noted that there was 10 times less fish in the Gulf of Thailand in 1995 than in 1965 while Malaysia experienced an 80 per cent to 90 per cent plunge.
The cod fishery in the North Sea collapsed over a decade ago. The giant bluefin schools found off the east coast of the United States are history.
Apparently, only 10 per cent of the big fish are left.
While it is undeniable that the shark's fin trade is partly responsible for the decline in the shark population, the problem cannot be seen in isolation and must be part of a holistic approach that looks at overall fish populations.
Even if the shark's fin trade is stopped, will that save the sharks? If the seas continue to be pillaged of fish, they too will disappear. Yet, certain groups that promote sustainability of the sea focus mainly on shark's fin.
Could these groups be swayed emotionally by gruesome videos showing live finning? What proportion of shark's fin is derived from live finning?
Perhaps measures could be taken to have shark's fin labelled to differentiate those finned after death, in the manner of 'dolphin safe' tuna meat.
The focus on shark sustainability alone is akin to guarding a particular tree in the forest against loggers, while the rest of the forest around it is burning. One may save that tree from the loggers, but unless one douses the fire, that tree too will eventually perish.
If one is serious about sustainability, one must look at the bigger picture.
The decline in overall marine resources will soon lead to the end of sharks, even if they are not caught for their fins.

Steven Lauw

[What seductive logic! The fish stocks are already low! If we leave the sharks alone, they will eat the fish and we will have even less fish to feed humans! Even if we don't eat them with the depleted fish stocks, the sharks will die of starvation anyway. Better for us to eat thier fins before they die (of starvation) and their fins rot away.

Yeah. protecting sharks is like protecting one tree in the fiorest from loggers while the rest of the forest burns. Instead the protectors should focus on trying to put out the fire. Meanwhile the loggers can cut down the tree undisturbed by the tree-huggers. Or the shark-huggers.

Here's another analogy. The shark conservationists are like a store security trying to prevent shop-lifting, but meanwhile the store is burning! I'm just a shopper who sees that if I just leave the store because of the fire, all the goods in the store will burn. So when I see an iPad I think, If I just go, the iPad will burn and be destroyed. What a waste! I shall save the iPad and take it with me. This is also saving the environment. The amount of energy to manufacture an iPad would be wasted if it were destroyed in the fire.

The self-justifying looter.]

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Opposition in Disarray

Mar 2, 2011

Instead of forming a single party, agree on straight fights against PAP

GETTING opposition parties to unite against the People's Action Party (PAP) in a general election is unconstructive, impractical and unworkable ('Only a united opposition can succeed' by Mr Paul Chan; last Saturday).
Simply merging different parties together would mean that weaker individuals and ineffective groups get conveniently subsumed into the association.
Given the challenging roles and duties of opposition politicians, there should be competition between parties - in the form of leadership calibre, manifestoes and overall quality.
As the immediate goal of opposition parties is to increase party credibility and persuade people to vote for them, they cannot compromise on their policy proposals and recommendations.
As they are motivated by varying ideals, though bound by the common purpose of serving the people, there are significant differences in their strategies for a better Singapore.
Also, the different levels of development among opposition parties may also deter the establishment of a single party.
Case in point: The resignations and confusing developments that appear to have roiled the new Reform Party contrast sharply with the situation in more established parties whose game plans are in place and well-articulated.
Merging into a single bloc now will result in valuable time and resources being wasted on wrangling over leadership positions and bickering over bureaucratic imbroglios, instead of focusing on substantive policy issues.
A call for unity without proper justification will hardly convince Singaporeans of the opposition's readiness to challenge the status quo.
Nonetheless, what opposition parties can - and should - do is to discuss the distribution of their candidates across the electoral map, to prevent three-way fights.
This would prevent splitting the opposition vote. More importantly, straight fights against the PAP will ensure contests in all constituencies, and allow all eligible Singaporeans to have their say at the ballot box.

Kwan Jin Yao


Disunity is obstructing an effective by-election strategy

WHEN the by-election strategy was hatched 20 years ago, it worked because the leaders of the opposition parties then were united ('Only a united opposition can succeed' by Mr Paul Chan; last Saturday).
The strategy was a hit as it garnered the opposition four seats in the 1991 General Election (GE), a record since Singapore's first GE for Parliament in 1968 when the People's Action Party (PAP) was returned to power on Nomination Day, and when walkovers became virtually a permanent feature thereafter.
A by-election strategy is still relevant. However, with so many opposition parties and self-centred leaders, it is almost impossible now.
One minor disagreement among opposition candidates would result in one of them joining or forming another political party.
The reality is that some opposition candidates can barely hope to keep their election deposits in a GE.
Opposition parties should pick their candidates more carefully.
For instance, those who are older than 60 and have lost in two GEs should refrain from contesting.
In fact, I think the opposition parties cannot find the 43 effective candidates they would need for a by-election strategy in the upcoming GE.
For example, if the Workers' Party can find five credible candidates like party chairman Sylvia Lim, it may have a chance of winning Aljunied GRC by employing the by-election strategy, on the assumption that the PAP is assured of forming the next government on Nomination Day.

Lim Jit Chaing

[The By-election effect has already been discredited. It was really the LKY effect. Or more precisely, the LKY stepping down effect. That was the year GCT took over. Some people obviously thought, if LKY is not PM, perhaps it is time to consider alternatives.

However, of the 4 opposition voted in that year, 2 were duds. Instead of heralding a new phase in opposition politics, they were a blip on the political radar and a lesson that alternatives need to be credible, viable, feasible, and presentable. The people learnt their lesson and rewarded Chiam and Low, and promptly kicked out the two twits in the next election.

And it has been two ever since.

To counter the By-election effect, the PAP has implemented local election effect with upgrading and asset enhancement offered to "buy" votes. It was worked, but now with most precincts upgraded, there is less to offer.

But the real reason the opposition is in disarray is that the PAP has no ideological weakness, simply because it has no ideology. The members of the opposition flit from one part to another because in the absence of an ideology, the opposition are unable to present a logical, coherent alternative.

If they have an ideology, it is that the PAP is pro-Singapore. And how can any opposition decide to campaign on an Anti-Singapore platform?

Before the opposition even can decide to oppose the PAP, they need to decide what are they opposing? You can oppose policies, but policies can change. You need to oppose principles and ideologies. Or provide an alternative.

Without a ideological or principle platform, all that the opposition can do is oppose policies, which is a weak platform.]

Tackle inflation now

Mar 2, 2011

THE Government has made a strong push in this year's Budget to raise real median incomes over the long term, while Mr Low Thia Khiang of the Workers' Party has called for immediate measures to lower price pressures on consumers by reducing the goods and services tax and reining in the price increases on essential items ('Who will win inflation debate?'; yesterday).
While both measures are at opposite ends of the spectrum of methods to tackle inflation, one via incomes, and the other via prices, the two types of measures are not mutually exclusive. It is possible for a combination of both to be used.
Raising real incomes will take time, and such measures will take effect only in the medium to long term.
However, inflation has been a significant problem in the past two to three years, with headline inflation numbers going past 3 per cent more often than not, in stark contrast to the period of sustained low inflation that our economy enjoyed in the previous five to 10 years.
Even if the difficult task of increasing productivity to raise real incomes is successful, the roaring inflation that we are currently experiencing would have already done very significant damage to lower-income families in the interim period.
There are even calls from other voices in the Government to be wary of the harm that inflation has on the social mobility of lower-income families.
Inflation is a clear and present danger that, if not tackled with immediate measures, will do harm that even medium- to longer-term measures cannot repair.
While the Government's plans to raise real incomes are laudable, now is not the time to stand back and allow inflation to rear its ugly head in the short term.
I urge the Government to consider more broad-based short-term measures to tackle inflation, in addition to its longer-term plans.
Tan Jiaqi

[There are perhaps three causes to inflation. One, increased demand, not enough supply. Two, too little supply. Three, too much money supply, with money losing value.

The first situation is happening. As China gets richer, it wants more cars, it wants more goods, it wants better food. As it ramps up its growth in manufacturing, it wants more raw material and it wants more energy, specifically, oil. World demand is rising. You want to stop inflation? How do you stop China?

The second situation is happening. Floods and cyclones in Australia devastated crops and supplies of raw materials. Unrest in the middle east is disrupting oil supplies. Increase cost of oil is raising the cost of transporting food and goods around the world. Chicken from Brazil will cost more when the cost of transporting them increase. How do you ensure supply of food and goods are not affected by weather events and political events?

Reduce GST? And replace that with what?

Subsidise food? For how long? Isn't it more focused to give cash to low income?]

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Columnist's selective view [Acupuncture]

Feb 23, 2011

AS A champion of evidence-based medicine, Dr Andy Ho never fails to highlight little molehills of evidence that cast the slightest doubts on the efficacy and safety of complementary and alternative medicine such as acupuncture, homeopathy, chiropractic and bioresonance ("Pinning down acupuncture: It's a placebo", Feb 12; "Indefensible ideas behind homeopathy", Jan 22; "Perils of chiropractic neck manipulation", Jan 21; "Sending out the wrong signals", Nov 6, 2010).
Yet he turns a blind eye to the huge mountains of scientific evidence that point to the harm and/or ineffectiveness of medical treatments and procedures, including:
- arthritis drugs, cholesterol-lowering drugs, diabetes drugs, anti-depressants, anti-viral drugs for flu and other drugs;
- medical tests such as magnetic resonance imaging;
- chemotherapy;
- vaccination;
- unnecessary surgery; and
- dental amalgams that contain toxic mercury.
Iatrogenic disease - which refers to illness caused by medical treatment, including medical errors, infections picked up at hospitals and "acceptable" drug side effects - has become a serious problem. Some medical commentators have statistics to show that it is now the third-leading cause of death in medically advanced countries like the United States.
Dr Ho is also largely silent about the many scandals involving fraudulent medical research, data cover-ups, negative studies that go unreported when they fail to prove a drug's safety or effectiveness, and other unethical practices of the pharmaceutical industry, all of which cast serious doubt on the validity of the "evidence" that support drug-based medicine.

Richard Seah

[There is a difference between saying that western medical science has errors and scandals and saying that acupuncture in theory and practice is based on erroneous assumptions, and unsupported beliefs, and has no efficacy beyond that of a placebo effect.

Western medicine is not perfect. Drugs have side effects, precisely because it has effects. (Viagra's efficacy as an impotence cure was originally a side effect.) The difference is between having a falsifiable, testable hypothesis to gather evidence for one or another conclusion. Western medicine continues to test and retest hypotheses. Sometimes human failings short cut the process and drugs or treatment are approved when they should not. But there are remedies and channels to correct these mistakes.

There are no such peer review or scientific approach to alternative medicine. If such review exists there is no rigour to the review. Unlike western medicine which has competing opinions and testing of hypothesis, alternate medicine practitioners all have a vested interest in an autistic conspiracy to prove their practices' efficacy.

Studies published by China's TCM show only half a bell curve in terms of the efficacy of acupunture. The believer will say that this shows that acupuncture works because even the least effective treatment showed positive effect. The skeptic will suspect that the authorities only publish positive supportive studies.

You never hear of side effects or overdose by homeopathy. There are no reports of misapplication of acupuncture resulting in an inadvertent result or side effect. You never hear of a misapplied needle leading to some unintended side effect.

Either every acupuncturist is so well-trained and so experienced that there is no misdiagnosis, no misapplication of the needles, and no side effect, or very simply, nothing is happening.

Similarly, you can't overdose on homeopathy cos there's nothing there.]

Friday, February 18, 2011

Salaries of Charities staff

Feb 19, 2011

Working for charity is about the heart, not the pay

I DON'T agree with Dr Keith Goh's letter on Monday ("If you pay peanuts, you get...."). In any commercial organisation where profit is the prime objective, if you pay peanuts, you get lousy chief executive officers (CEOs). In a charity organisation, the operating principle is not profit-orientated and you need only a CEO with passion to do the job, on a decent salary.

[Define "decent". Is market rate "decent"? What if you don't have CEOs with passion? Would CEOs with professional pride do? "You need only a CEO with passion". So no need competence, ability, imagination, etc? ]

A well-run charity organisation delivers efficiently the donated dollar value to the intended beneficiary. Its reputation and good deeds will attract more donors. The CEO does not need charisma but rather diligence.

[And you want to reward the diligence with... gratitude instead of a reasonable compensation? Which is better a CEO with passion, heart, but limited competence willing to work cheap, or a CEO with competence, diligence, professionalism, and a good work ethic but who could work in any other sector, and make a good living to support his family and so require compensation commensurate with his experience and ability?]

Take, for example, the Thong Chai Charity Night held in March last year to raise funds for the 143-year-old Singapore Thong Chai Medical Institution. It raised $8.6 million, far exceeding the targeted amount of $3.5 million in a single event. The response was overwhelming and testified to the spirit and dedication of the organisation.

[Again, the criteria the unwashed public seems to use for determining charities' "success" seems to be their fund-raising capability. If so, NKF under Durai was the most successful charity ever. A charity's main objective should be to provide the help that it was set up to do first and foremost. Fund-raising is to resource that objective. But because fund-raising is so much easier to measure, so much easier to distill to a single figure, it becomes the sole measure of a charity's "success". ]

The free hospital sees more than 700 patients a day with only 51 employees at a total manpower cost of just below $1.26 million. I salute the leaders of this charity organisation for working in the true spirit of charity.

Giving to charity is a personal sacrifice from the heart for the needy and underprivileged in our community, and serving a charity organisation is to answer the noble calling to serve society.

[And if no one answers the call? In the first generation people work for free or cheap because of passion. But for sustained growth, you need to professionalise by the second or third generation of leaders. Harping on passion without understanding the complexities of running an organisation, let alone a charity is parochial, short-sighted, idealistic, and unrealistic. You want to do that, you need to establish your own religious order, and breed your own monks and nuns who would be willing to work for the sheer passion of it. But competence would be hit or miss. ]

I see no reason why charity organisations should pay big salaries to their CEOs when all volunteers work for free to conserve donated funds for intended beneficiaries. There is no place in charity organisations for high-fliers and ambitious managers. People who choose to work there should have the right mindset.

[And we'll forgive the wrong skillset because you're willing to work cheap. And that is why the social sector is struggling to improve.]

Paul Chan


Feb 19, 2011

Integrity, not money, must be the decisive incentive

I DISAGREE with Dr Keith Goh ("If you pay peanuts, you get..."; Monday) that it is all right to pay hefty salaries to leaders of charities.

If leaders are motivated solely by monetary benefits, they might as well work for a profit-driven organisation instead of for a charity whose sole object is to help the needy.

[Exactly. So most of the competent professionals are shunning the Charity sector, that's why the charities have been trying to attract competent people with more pay. But public reactions like this are going to frighten off potential leaders. If you impose such ridiculous burden on them - to work for free or cheap - they will think about their families, the scrutiny, the public disapproval, and say, "I don't need this" and go work for a bank.

Your unrealistic ideals are in the way of charities trying to improve their governance and capability. Your ideals are keeping them dumb and depriving the disadvantaged of good service.]

Recent cases where leaders of charities were brought to trial for their dishonesty highlight the need to have charity leaders with integrity. Those convicted of wrongdoing were no doubt talented, but were greedy and lacked integrity.

We must learn from these past experiences and not use money as an incentive to attract the wrong talent to run charities.

[So we'll depend on competent people with good hearts willing to work for free or for very little. Unfortunately Mother Teresa is dead, and while I think she has a good heart, and an inspirational leader, I have no idea about her ability as a CEO.

We don't need priests and nuns and monks. We need leaders. Competent leaders who know how to manage charities as viable organisations, not as well-meaning amateurs whose hearts are in the right place but everything else is in the wrong place.]

William Tay


Feb 19, 2011

Personal sacrifice required of charity CEOs

DR KEITH Goh's letter on Monday ("If you pay peanuts, you get...") re-ignites the debate as to whether charity honchos should be paid market rates on a par with chief executive officers (CEOs) of public-listed companies, or whether they should be recruited on the basis of their passion first and foremost.

Dr Goh described the various duties expected of a charity boss, certainly no less onerous than those of a public-listed company's CEO, but he overlooked one big difference.

A charity boss is not only expected to give of his best to the charity he serves, but also to do this at some personal sacrifice. His love for and dedication to the cause of the charity should be his primary motivation, not how much he will get in terms of salary. This is so, notwithstanding that he may have attributes befitting of a more lucrative position as a CEO in a public-listed company.

True, such a person is hard to come by. But so is any good company CEO. Nevertheless, they are there if the search is genuine and relentless.

We should not compromise faithfulness to a cause with opportunism or profit motivation.

Yap Swee Hoo

[All these writers think that Charities are suddenly deciding that what the hey, let's pay big bucks and get some high-flyer CEO just for the heck of it? Let's see, we need someone with integrity, passion, and competence. The Dalai Lama is not available (still fighting for Tibet's independence). The Pope... hmmm not exactly sure that he's cheap. Mother Teresa's dead. Gandhi too. Jesus Christ long dead (or resurrected according to some). Dammit! Messiahs, Saviours and Saints only come once every few hundred years and we have like 300 social service charities needing good leaders.

So sit around and search and search for a saint? Or work with what we've got, and realise that talent needs to be compensated (or they'll work elsewhere).

These writers should ask themselves. If their son or daughter graduated with high honours and distinctions and then decided to follow their passion and work in a charity for a token salary just enough to pay their living expenses would they worry for their child? If they had spent their savings to give their child the education they wanted and now depend on their child to support them in their old age, would their child's choice worry them? Of course it should not! Because since the child is in the charity sector, the parents will have priority admission to old age home, nursing home and other social services!]