Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Make tax system simpler for rented-out property

Jan 18, 2011

THE Government has introduced progressive tax rates on property tax for owner-occupied properties from this year. Properties that are rented out will continue to be taxed at 10 per cent of the annual value.

The Government should consider extending the progressive tax rate system for rented out properties and remove property income from the income tax returns. There is no need for the same income to be taxed twice - as property tax and income tax - especially as the taxes are based on the market-adjusted annual value of the property.

[Rental income to different people are tax differently. If you have an annual salary of $100,000 and have property bringing in $20,000 annually in rent, you will pay a higher income tax. If you have just one property bringing in just $20,000, but is otherwise unemployed, you pay zero income tax. So you don't pay the same tax for the same property.

For an ex-CEO, you don't seem to be able to see the whole picture.]

The progressive tax rate on rented properties can be made to mirror the revenue that is currently collected by the Government from the income tax levied on the rental income.

[How? It will have to take into account other income. So might as well figure it out by income tax returns.]

As an owner of property that has been rented out, I now find it a hassle to compute the net property income to submit in my income tax returns. I must identify the rental income and expenses that are expended on the property, such as property tax, insurance, repairs, maintenance charges, agency fee and other items.

[Hassle, then don't own property. Don't rent out. Singapore's tax code is already one of the most simplified.]

It is unclear if the owner is allowed to deduct the proportion of the rental that is set aside for furnishing of the property.

[Then find out. You only need to do it once.]

The complexity can be removed when the income tax portion is integrated into the proposed progressive rate on rented out properties. It will also save a lot of work for the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore in policing the reporting of rental income.

Tan Kin Lian

[And now, how about NO tax?]

Jan 23, 2011
YOUR LETTERS
Adopt fairer tax system for owner-occupiers

The basis of assessment of property tax is the same regardless of whether a property is let, owner-occupied or vacant, while the annual value reflects its monthly gross rent. This is the stand of the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (Iras).

The rationale for it is fair when the property generates income and the owner can deduct the property tax paid as expenses against rental incomes in computing his income-tax return.

It remains fair if an owner-occupied property generating no income is exempted.

But it becomes a burden and is unfair when the owner of a wholly owner-occupied property has to pay tax for essentially 'no income'.

The actual tax I have paid over the past six assessment years, for instance, reflects this burden and shows the exponential rise of property tax.

Apart from a substantial rebate in 2009, the rising trend has been fast and furious. For instance, the tax increased by virtually 2.29 times from March 2007 to January last year.

[You neglect to mention that for owner-occupier, property tax is tiered, and progressive concessionary. Whereas for leased out premises, the property tax is a flat 10% with no concession. Secondly, the annual valuation is way under-valued (at least for HDB flats). So if you own & occupy a 3-rm flat, you may well pay no taxes, or minimal property tax.

If the annual value of your flat is $65k or less (monthly rental of about $5.5k which would put it in the landed property category), you'd pay 4%, and if you exceed $65k, the excess of $65k will be taxed at 6%.]

Economic transformation and changing landscapes improve standards of living but do not change the intrinsic values of property where the owners, through no fault of their own and for whatever reasons, choose to live in the same house for many decades.

The rental incomes of their neighbours have nothing to do with this group of owners, as they still live in their homes with no income generated.

The present system is unfair and not 'owner-occupied friendly'.

Iras should isolate unrelated factors like prevailing rental yield, market fluctuation and economic growth, and consider the factor of 'no income' to exempt owner-occupied property.

[If you have no income, you pay no income tax. If you have no property, you pay no property tax. If your property is expensive, then maintaining it is probably also expensive. If you can afford to maintain it, you should be able to afford to pay property tax. If you bought property 20 or more years ago, you are extremely fortunate. Young couple today can't afford the high prices of even HDB flats. The value of your property increasing is not your doing, but the entire neighbourhood and what the authorities did to raise the value of your neighbourhood. That is what the tax is a proxy for. If you are retired and living in a highly desirable location for working people who can benefit more from your strategic location, then it makes sense for you to give up the location so someone else can gain more from it. Perhaps he will commute less, pay less for fuel, spend less time on the road.]

Perhaps a more reasonable approach is to use 'date of purchase' to peg property valuation as the basic quantum.

Paul Chan

[It's not all about you. Or your situation. Or how life has passed you by. Or why you should need special treatment. Or about maintaining your way of life for your convenience. Or what you are used to. It's about redistributing resources for what's best for the nation.

Taxes are a way of redistributing wealth. If you bought your property a long time ago when it was relatively cheap, then you have really made a gain. Compared to your children who today have to fork out 10 times what you paid for a flat half the size of your property or even less, is it fair for the younger generation to pay higher property tax for a small property while you being from an earlier generation who had the opportunity to buy property when it was relatively cheap pay little or no property tax on a huge property?


Taxes are a crude instrument to do that, but it's the best we've got.]

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Young S'poreans keen to hear MM Lee's views

Jan 16, 2011

They are curious to find out what he has to say on issues that concern the young

When Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew stepped down as prime minister in 1990, Mr Cheo Ming Shen was just six, so his memory of Singapore's founding leader is hazy at best.

But that did not stop the 27-year-old co-founder of Internet start-up Netccentric from ordering an autographed copy of a new book on Mr Lee. He was among 60 donors who will get a limited edition signed copy of the book, having donated $10,000. Proceeds go to The Straits Times School Pocket Money Fund.

'There is nobody bigger than MM in Singapore,' said Mr Cheo, who has read and owns both volumes of Mr Lee's memoirs. 'He is the equivalent of Nelson Mandela to Singaporeans.'

[Really? LKY was locked up for 27 years for sabotaging govt while fighting racial discrimination? Then on his release, won election to lead the country. And promoted reconciliation between the races? And won the Nobel Peace Prize?

I think comparing LKY to Mandela is an incredible (and wholly inappropriate) compliment to LKY. Not sure if Mandela would feel complimented though.

And most importantly, "he's Nelson Mandela to Singaporeans"? I think 70% of Singaporeans don't know who is Nelson Mandela. And 30% don't know who Lee Kuan Yew is.

This normally would be in the other blog, but my intended comments bumped it here.]

Monday, January 10, 2011

Spare pet owners the 'D' word

Jan 11, 2011

RECENTLY, my dog passed away and I had to deregister it on the Agri-Food and Veterinary Authority website.
On the site, under the given options for reasons for deregistration, the first one is the word "dead" followed by others such as "lost", "stolen" and so on.
We are already feeling very sad over the loss of our dog and it is insensitive to have such a word on the site. Is it possible to change it to something like "passed on"?
This would really go a long way towards helping dog owners get over their grief.
Elizabeth Chiona (Ms)


Latest comments (online)
It's an official form, with factual reasons for the cancellation of a license. Why whould AVA use euphemisms? Instead of "Dead", "Lost" and "Stolen", why not "Moved to the Big Kennel in the Sky", "No Longer at Home, but surely Trying to Find his way back to My Loving Arms" and "Liberated by Less Than Honest Individuals, Current Whereabouts Unknown, but Sorely Missed"? The dog is dead, deal.
Posted by: agooddaytodie at Tue Jan 11 10:32:07 SGT 2011

[I think the online comment was harsh enough. :-) ]

Saturday, January 8, 2011

Works there, why not here?

TODAY
Jan 04, 2011

Letter from Rick Lim Say Kiong

I AM worried. Despite the assortment of pro-family measures dished out by the Government over the years to address Singapore's low fertility rate, it continues to drop further ("S'pore grapples with low birth rate, integration", Dec 31).

While our total population is steadily increasing, we are aware that this is due mostly to the number of transient workers and immigrants who become Permanent Residents (PR). Singaporeans have groused about this massive influx of foreigners. The nub of their complaints is not only with the number, but also the quality, of the immigrants.

We can all agree that we need transient workers for jobs in sectors such as construction, food and beverage, and cleaning. Since these industries have been reluctant to increase wages or improve productivity, foreign labour seems to be the only option at the moment to meet manpower demands. What we need to be concerned about, however, are immigrants not working in these labour-intensive industries.

As a human resource practitioner, I have noticed that the quality of workers applying for and obtaining permanent residence has decreased over the years. In the past, when the Government was espousing the need for foreign talent to work here, start businesses and create jobs for Singaporeans, potential PR applicants had degrees, diplomas or higher-level certificates and/or a wealth of experience.

[Since you are HR practitioner, tell us why the market is not paying more wages to Singaporeans, or why productivity is stagnating. You should be in the know. If the new FW are lower quality, why is your HR practice to hire lower quality FW?]

In the last six years, however, I have noticed that even workers with three O-Level credits are granted PR status once they have worked here for a year or two. Skilled as they may be, do they contribute to our economy by creating jobs or do they take jobs that can be done by locals? If only real foreign talents are given PR to work and stay here, and they do create jobs for the locals, then my guess is that most Singaporeans would not mind their growing numbers.

We need to worry about why we cannot arrest the decline in our fertility rate when pro-fertility measures implemented in other developed countries seem to work. In Australia, the goal is to reach a fertility rate of 2.1. Their current rate is 2.0 - impressive if you compare that to our dismal figure of 1.22 last year.

Australia has flexible working arrangements for employees, dating agencies for singles and a government-run baby bonus scheme for parents - which we also have in Singapore - yet theirs seem to work and ours do not. Why?

[So why don't you tell us why it works in Australia? We don't know why ours don't work. If we knew, don't you think we would have fixed it? Since you know Australia's work, did you dig a little deeper and get an analysis of why it worked there?]

One contributor to the Today online forum puts it aptly with this analogy: When pandas in a forest are not reproducing themselves sufficiently, do you add other bears to the forest (where resources are scarce) and then expect the panda numbers to increase?

[Depends. The bears were introduced to eat berries and salmon. Pandas only eat bamboo. Not very versatile. Impossible to reskill. And if resources (bamboo) are scarce, don't worry. Bears don't eat bamboo.]

When we find that our spaces get more cramped, wages do not increase, modes of public transport are packed, jobs are threatened, housing options are becoming limited and their cost increased, et cetera, it does not take much to realise that these factors will impact our country's fertility rate.

[Bullshit. One of the biggest problems in poor countries are high births among poor people living in cramp conditions, with low stagnating wages, or no jobs, and no housing options. All the points you raise are our government's insidious efforts to make Singaporeans feel poor so that they will produce more babies.

And that was a facetious way of saying, those are excuses, not reasons. Sometimes they are fodder for blackmail. You see it in forum pages: If the govt wants me to have more kids, they should help me get a flat!]


In addition, our long working hours and demanding workloads are the main killers of fertility. Having better maternity benefits, flexible work arrangements and baby bonus schemes are measures that treat only the symptoms of our underlying problems - and until we truly fix these, our fertility rate is likely to continue its decline.

[So to reduce long working hours, and demanding workloads, we need to hire more people, and since there are no more people of the required quality, we need to hire more... FOREIGNERS! Which means that Singapore will get more crowded and housing costs increase and people worry about their jobs, so they DON'T HAVE BABIES!

You haven't really thought through this problem, have you?]

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Time for a new formula?

Explore a way to de-link property tax from rental values driven by foreigners

Dec 30, 2010

Letter from Thian Tai Chew

WITH effect from Jan 1, 2011, Singapore's property tax will shift from a flat 4-per-cent rate to a system of progressive property tax rates based on Annual Values (AV) of these properties. As a result, I will save about 8 per cent of the property tax payable for next year. Am I happy with this saving?

Let's look at the formula for calculating the property tax rate. It is based on the annual value of your property.

According to the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore's (IRAS) circular, the AV is the estimated market rent if the property were to be let. It is determined based on the market rentals of comparable properties.

It is no secret that the rental market in Singapore is heavily influenced by the demand from foreigners working in Singapore. The more foreigners we attract here, the higher the demand for rental housing and, hence, higher rental rates.

It begs the question then - why should property tax be tagged to the influx of foreigners coming into Singapore ?

I am not against paying property tax, but I am against the link of property tax to the demand by foreigners coming to Singapore to work.

These foreigners, most of whom would go for rental housing, do not pay property tax. It is fair to assume that landlords would have already priced the property tax into the rental, hence jacking up the rental prices, which in turn would jack up the property tax as the AVs are now higher.

It is a vicious cycle and as long as we continue to attract more foreigners into Singapore, the only outcome for such a formula is that the property tax would go higher and higher.

As an owner-occupied property owner who does not partake of the rental market, I do not see why I should be taxed based on the actions of other people who are renting out their property.

Since the Government has explicitly mentioned that attracting foreign talents will remain as one of our national policies, the property tax moving forward is going only one way - up.

I do not see the rationale for paying property tax that is linked to the outcome of another unrelated policy.

It's time for the IRAS to explore a formula that would de-link the property tax from rental values that are heavily influenced by the influx of foreigners.

So the answer to my earlier question: Am I happy with the tax savings for next year? Yes, any saving is always good, but I do not like what is coming beyond 2011.

[Eh, goondu. Owner-occupier pays concessionary tax. Owners who rent or sublets their flats pay 10%. Your 4% is a concessionary rate.

More importantly, the annual value is ridiculously undervalued! (don't tell IRAS!) You look at your property tax bill and tell me you will rent your flat for annual rent equivalent to the AV assessed by IRAS.

Three room HDB flats have AVs of less than $7000 (that's about $550 per month. FOR THE WHOLE FLAT! Four rooms' AV is less than $9000 or less than $750 pm for the whole flat. This is SERIOUS under-valuation. But I don't believe IRAS is stupid. I believe this is another way they give tax concession to home owners.

So don't ask stupid questions about new formula for property tax. You are already getting a GREAT DEAL!

Idiot!]

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Upsized out of a lucky draw

Dec 29, 2010

ENTICED by a "Say Aloha to the teriyaki chicken sandwich" promotion - and a chance to win a holiday in a lucky draw - outside the Carl's Jr restaurant at Jurong Point, my wife and I decided to try out the new teriyaki chicken sandwich for lunch on Monday.

When placing our orders, the counter employee asked if I would like to upsize my meal and I agreed on the upsize and I added on another pack of onion rings.

After being served our meal, we realised we were not given any entry coupon for the lucky draw. I then approached the counter and the manager asked to see my receipt. He said because I had upsized my meal, I did not qualify for the draw.

Surely this should be clearly stated so that customers would know not to upsize and pay extra if they do not want to be deprived of the lucky draw opportunity.

Alvin Alexis

[Ok. Granted Carl's Jr marketing and promotion is a little weird. This is a completely strange way of running a promotion. BUT if your choice of lunch is decided by lucky draws and freebies... you don't really know what you want do you?

Put another way. When you upsized your meal, you became a premium customer to Carl's Jr who then felt that it was not nice to have their premium customer's particulars added to the list that they were going to sell to telemarketers. Therefore they didn't give you your lucky draw coupon where you will have a 1 in 8 million chance of winning a holiday (terms and conditions apply, holiday must commence no earlier than the 26 Dec 2011 and be completed before the 31st Dec. Action figures sold separately. Batteries not included. Actual holiday may differ from illustration. Alcoholic beverages are chargeable. Offer void where prohibited by law. Prizes are not exchangeable or refundable), and will definitely be harassed by 352 telemarketers over the next 2 months.

You got the better deal.]

Friday, December 24, 2010

Japan's Strategic Position

Dec 25, 2010

Don't shunt history into a corner

I REFER to the commentary by academic Heng Yee Kuang ('Best not to push Japan into a corner'; Tuesday).

Japan is not a landlocked country. It has access in all directions - by air or sea.

[Thus implying that Japan cannot be cornered and has strategic maneuverability. Which is stupid. Move where? So someone attacks from the east, and Japan moves it's entire force to the west? Someone invades your exclusive economic zone in the south, and you just move your fishing fleet to the north? Dumb.]

After the recent incident involving a collision between a Chinese fishing boat and a Japanese patrol boat near the Diaoyu/Senkaku islands, the 'sleeping giant' suddenly woke up and started announcing new changes in defence policy.

Its focus seems to be to ensure that this claimed territory in the East China Sea remains under Japanese control.

So, where did the writer find evidence of China trying to corner Japan?

[China making a big incident out of it, demanding the release of the Chinese captain charged with ramming the Japanese defence force vessel, demanding restitution, threatening sanctions, cutting off rare earth minerals exports to Japan, etc. And by the way, the article was not just about China. The article pointed out that Japan is being pressured by China and Russia, with N.Korea as a bit player. That the writer focus only on China shows a flawed and biased reading of the article. ]

The article quoted a Japanese academic's concern that 'Japan might be compelled to contemplate the possibility of re-fighting China once again'. Re-fight China? Who invaded whom in the past? Let us not forget history.

[And here the penny dropped. Yes, since Japan invaded China and committed atrocities such as the Nanking massacre, this now entitles China to get what's fair, eh?]

Chen Sen Lenn


Dec 21, 2010

Best not to push Japan into a corner

By Heng Yee Kuang

JAPAN'S announcement of sweeping changes to its defence postures last week reflects mounting strategic unease at being trapped in the increasingly rough neighbourhood of North East Asia. This sense of multiple threats bearing down on the nation from various directions was conveyed by Defence Minister Toshimi Kitazawa, who said: 'Our country is encircled by severe security situations...'

To begin with, there were the 'pincer movements' by China and Russia ganging up to press home their advantage. A joint statement released by Presidents Hu Jintao and Dmitri Medvedev in September soon after the Senkaku/Diaoyu trawler incident had both sides agreeing to support each other's 'core interests', including national sovereignty, unity and territorial integrity (code words for territorial disputes in Japanese eyes). Coincidentally or not, President Medvedev then became the first Russian leader to visit the disputed Kurile islands shortly afterwards. While unrelated, North Korea's shelling of the South's Yeonpyeong island further stoked the feeling of a Japan under siege.

Putting the squeeze on Tokyo not only has the potential to awaken the sleeping giant, but can also backfire on Moscow and Beijing. In my discussions with leading academics, military officials and students in Tokyo, I found there was apprehension about how the Japanese people will react to such pressure. One young student said to me that he was very concerned about the nationalist backlash from the younger generation frustrated at Japan's weakness.

Although young Japanese are usually depicted as more interested in anime and manga than high politics, one Internet opinion poll earlier this month of 500 teens in junior high school rated the Senkaku clash as the news story of 2010.

More than its gaffes, the Naoto Kan Cabinet suffers heavily from a perception of its diplomatic weakness. Plummeting opinion polls are front-page headlines on leading dailies like the Asahi Shimbun.

A Fuji News Network survey showed the Cabinet's approval rating plunging to 21.8 per cent early this month. Protests denouncing both China and the Kan government have attracted crowds in the low thousands, a relatively large number in Japan. Cabinet Office data released last Sunday indicates the number of Japanese who feel favourable towards China has reached a low of 20 per cent, dropping 18.5 percentage points in just a year.

China was once viewed as more an opportunity than a threat. The previous Hatoyama administration came to power peddling the notion of closer ties with China and distancing Japan from America. However, China's recent assertiveness has pushed Tokyo back into Washington's embrace.

The new National Defence Programme Guidelines document employs the strongest language ever used to describe China's military modernisation and maritime activities. 'These movements, coupled with the lack of transparency in its military and security matters,' the document asserts, 'have become a matter of concern for the region and the international community.' The previous guideline in 2004 merely said Tokyo would be 'attentive' to China's future intentions.

As a result, Japan will now re-deploy forces to the remote south-west Nansei Shoto island group where China has territorial claims, abandoning its Cold War focus on a Soviet invasion of northern Hokkaido. More submarines, early warning radar systems and surface-to-ship missiles will be stationed closer to the disputed Senkaku islands to fill what the document calls a 'defence vacuum'. A second squadron of warplanes will also be added at Naha, Okinawa.

Despite its pacifist outlook, Japan's military is in fact larger than Britain's. It deploys the most advanced naval forces in the Pacific after the US Navy's Seventh Fleet. Japan also has one of the highest military budgets in the world. Deployments overseas have for years been testing the limits of the country's post- World War II pacifist Constitution.

Further provocation from Pyongyang, Beijing or Moscow will only provide more ammunition to those Japanese who are seeking to loosen the constitutional constraints on their country's military power. While no one seriously expects Japan to once again rampage across Asia, an expanded role for its technologically advanced Self-Defence Forces and a paradigm shift where Tokyo abandons engagement and confronts China directly is hardly in the interest of Beijing and Moscow.

Already, the latest guidelines hint at Japan's desire to break out of its 'encirclement' by courting allies such as Australia and South Korea. It should not be forgotten that Japan is considered widely to be a so-called 'virtual nuclear weapon state'. It can produce nuclear weapons relatively quickly.

A leading Japanese academic told me privately of his concern that Japan might be compelled to contemplate the possibility of re-fighting China once again. Do China and Japan really need several major wars, like the European powers did, before finally establishing structures for peace and cooperation? Full-blown conflict is certainly not yet on the cards but driving Japan into a corner would be a short-sighted and counter-productive move.

The writer, a Singaporean, is assistant professor of international relations at the University of St Andrews, Scotland. He is now a visiting scholar at Waseda University in Tokyo.

[The basic point of the article as I understand it is that extra-legal (or outright illegal) strategies regarding disputed territories will only raise the temperature of the issues, and may eventually spill over into confrontation. The proper approach is to use established international dispute resolution processes to sort out disagreements. However, that is not route being taken at the moment. Attitudes and postures "backed" by historical grievances as implied by the letter-writer serves little purpose, except to perhaps justify those extra-legal activities and strategies.

Still, there is a right and wrong way to go about protecting one's interest... ST Editorial below summarises.]


EDITORIAL
Japan right and wrong on defence posture

ANY Japanese government would be mindful that raising the nation's military preparedness, however justified, will cause unease. First is the arms buildup in North Asia extending to the subcontinent and South-east Asia. Japan's latest defence review stressing a rapid-response capability will accelerate the race. A buildup is inevitable anyway to keep trade routes open, but this is slight mitigation when productive spending should have priority in societies moving towards middle-income status. Second, countries that bore the brunt of the Japanese imperial advance during the last war will wonder whether the post-war pacifism, which held when Japan was peerless in Asia, is starting to unravel with China having displaced it. Unlike in Germany, militarist instincts are alive among sections of the Japanese elite. Thus, the incomplete atonement for wartime acts and denials of history.

And yet, and yet. Japan may end up looking not unduly aggressive for the new defence doctrine of meeting contingencies rather than imagining an old-fashioned invasion, from Russia for instance. The surprise of the military reassessment out last Friday was that it had not been updated sooner. In the six years since the last review undertaken by the Liberal Democrats, economic strides made by other Asian nations concurrent with force modernisation had left Japan looking under-invested. Maritime and territorial disputes in the East and South China seas in which Japan is involved have been longstanding. But North Asia is a changed theatre with China and South Korea more at odds as they progress, and North Korea defying norms of rational conduct as it prepares for leadership change. Then there is China's unstoppable growth in all fields of contest. Japan's treaty linkages with the United States oblige Tokyo to relook its defence posture in the light of what is spoken of as China's 'assertiveness', as if this is not a natural progression of gathering strength.

This is all very clinical on paper. In practice, Japan has needlessly got off badly with China by declaring that its realignment of forces to the south near China, and its spending on surveillance and missile systems are on account of its neighbour. In helping the US retain mobility in the Pacific, Japan should be emphasising it is defending the peace. And that this is essential for economic growth and recovery across the world. Then there will be no cause for fresh Beijing-Tokyo tension, which has arisen as China has objected to being targeted. Japan ought to take an all encompassing approach in relations with China, to stress also political and cultural collaboration. And military ties need not be a contradiction.