Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Few babies? It's the Hotel Mama mindset

[And now we bring you the tale of a sexually frustrated young man in Singapore...]

Sep 9, 2009

IT IS not by chance that Singapore has such a low fertility rate. There are many contributing factors, but an important one is the housing policy and the mindset behind it.

In Europe and the United States, people leave their homes in their early 20s or even earlier. With their salaries, they can afford to rent a place, maybe with a friend or two. Those aged 25 and above, who are still living at home, are considered strange, immature and lacking in independence.

In the West, people in their 20s experiment, enjoy their freedom and have probably more than one relationship before they settle down and start a family.

[And what are their TFR?]

In Singapore, it is a policy that only married couples can have an affordable, subsidised flat. It is way too expensive for someone who has just entered the workforce to rent or buy an apartment on the resale market. So they live with their parents and enjoy Hotel Mama, which is comfortable and saves them some money.

But they have to follow their parents' rules, such as, 'When I wake up, you have to be in your bed, alone'. Bringing a lover home is out of the question. For them, childhood continues until they are well into their 30s.

Is it then really surprising that there are not many babies?

[You really need to learn from our students. They somehow managed it. At home, when their parents are at work. At void decks, stairwells, holiday chalets, parks, etc. And they start as young as 10 now. and they don't need to be Americans or Europeans. :-)]

It is not just a question of having no private space. It is also a question of mentality. In the West, young people learn early to stand on their own feet, to take care of themselves, to live their own lives.

In Singapore, the young are conditioned to follow the rules, to live for their schools or jobs, to listen to their parents and to be obedient citizens.

But different qualities are needed for starting a family, such as readiness to take risks, independence and the ability to have fun.

[Ya. Those are the qualities to start a pregnancy. But the qualities to be a good parent should include sense of responsibility, discipline, resourcefulness, and tenacity.]

In Singapore, there is too much emphasis on obedience, too little on independence. That is not good for having babies.

[Wong (below) will say something about this. Much better than I can. You dodo.]

Some might say that Singapore has no choice because it is a small island. But I don't know any other big city which has so much empty land, even at the best locations next to underground train stations.

[There you are! have sex next to the train station!]

It seems to be the policy here to make available only a little land for buildings and to keep property prices sky-high.

[Damn! you found out our national secret. We'll have to stop you from procreating!]

Peter Huber

-------- online comments ---------
[And now, a comment from our resident misogynist & bigot:]

The writer, Peter Huber, is entitled to his theory to explain SG's low birth rate just like any of us. He may have something when he points to the high property prices ( as part of the high costs of living in general). In the main, though, he blames it on us for being docile obedient dodos when compared with the ("superior") risk-taking independent die-die-must-move-out Westerners. 
If he had put more thought into it, he might have noticed: 
1. When SG had a post-war baby boom, the pre-conditions to which he ascribes higher birth rates in the West didn't obtain then, in some ways even less than now. Rent was not cheap relative to income, extended families lived under-one-roof and social norms were far more conservative than now. 
2. In fact, in none of the Asian countries that experienced a baby boom were you likely to have found the pre-conditions to which the writer ascribes Western birth rates. Indeed, relative to these Asian countries during their baby boom years, Western birth rates were LOWER. 
3. He might have noticed that if we were indeed obedient docile dodos, we would NOT HAVE a birth rate problem because we would obey the exhortations of the govt and our own parents to pro-create.

[Bravo! *clap* *clap*. Wong, despite his misogyny, is an intelligent man. But then he goes on...]
But, of course, Mr. Huber was not really interested in a deeper look into his own theory. His letter was about ideology i.e. pushing the stock Western line about "superior" Western freedom versus stifling Asian conformity. Same ole same ole. This kind of superiority complex underpinned the whole era of overt imperialism and the thing to note is how alive and well it is up to now. (So much for the Westernised who claim differently.) 
 [No, no, Mr Wong. You're misinterpreting the sexual frustrations of a young man with no privacy with higher ideals. In doing so, you ridiculously elevate the testosterone ranting of a sex-starved young man to the level of a clash of civilisations. Samuel Huntington, he is not. Mr Wong is born in the wrong era. He would have made a wonderful anti-colonialist.]
Look, if we don't care for generalisations about Asian societies being "morally superior" to Western societies then we must recognise Mr. Huber's letter for what it is - merely a similar generalisation in the opposite direction. Come back when you have a real take on our problems, Mr. Huber, but spare us the cold war era ideological broadcast.
[And Mr Wong should take off his tunnel-vision glasses. :-) ]
Posted by: WongHoongHooi at Wed Sep 09 15:00:42 SGT 2009
...
[And now a word from our resident Anti-PAP...]
WongHoongHooi,
The reason for the stop at two policy was obvious - the govt projected the population based on the birth rates then (1960's) to be untenable for whatever developmental plans it had in mind.
And as they say, things tend to acquire their own momentum once things get rolling. One thing leads to another. Small families and policies designed as disincentive for having large families inevitably led to the 'nuclear' family, more liberal abortion law etc.
The stop at two policy became so ingrained in govt policy consideration order of the day that nobody gave a dot when reproduction rates dived below renewal level. And of course, the making of an aging population obviously crossed nobody's mind. The dominant thought was probably this: the overpopulation issue has been effectively
tackled. And it didn't help when the PM is such a dominant and overpowering figure that no well meaning and career minded senior civil servant dared to point out the looming problem to him in order to live another day1
What did people like Ngiam Tong Tow and the Chief Statistician who probably have the ears of the top do then?
I have a cynical belief that many probable did see the problem looming but were AFRAID to speak for they love their families' and their own future more.
THERE IS NO RUNNING AWAY FROM RESPONSIBILITY BY THE POLITICIANS IN THE MANNER THINGS TURN OUT IN A COUNTRY. THE BUCK STOPS SQUARELY AT THE DOOR STEP OF THE LEADERSHIP. IN THIS CASE WE KNOW WHO.
Posted by: commentator_sc at Wed Sep 09 16:22:24 SGT 2009
...

[Commentator was having such a good run, I didn't have the heart to interject. :-)

But this is a case study of hijacked agendas. Huber writes a barely disguised piece on his sexual frustration. which is translated by the anglophobe as an attack on his culture and rises to defend his civilisation while casting Huber in the role of imperialist. Then commentator comes along and says, "it's all LKY's fault!"

And that is a day in the life at the ST forum.

You have to laugh.]

Monday, August 3, 2009

Flaming vortex

Aug 4, 2009
Wanton use of fire for entertainment will work against green efforts

I REFER to the report "Flaming vortex gets Science Centre fired up" last Saturday.

While I am not against scientific research and activities that yield benefits for the planet and humankind, I feel that the wanton use of fire as entertainment or attraction is a spit in the face of pro-environmental efforts.

On the one hand, we are discussing the problem of forest fires in Indonesia and global warming on an unprecedented scale. On the other hand, we are burning fuel purely for the sake of entertaining people for a few minutes.

Not only that, the Singapore Science Centre is actually thinking of producing smaller versions of this invention for commercial sale.

Besides being a potential fire hazard, this invention goes against the green message: conserve energy and reduce global warming.

Aeronautics engineer Tsai Her Mann's invention can be used to demonstrate how fires may spread or grow in strength, but let us not waste resources on transient entertainment.

Adam Leo Isidore Tan
--------------

[Extreme Environmentalism. Next he would travel to Hawaii and terminate the employment of many fire entertainers. Think Global. Act Loco.]

--------------
Aug 1, 2009
Flaming vortex gets Science Centre fired up

A SWIRLING tornado of fire, 6m high, will be the showpiece of a fire exhibition at the Science Centre later this year.

Aeronautics engineer Tsai Her Mann has invented a structure which can channel wind to create the flaming vortex, and the centre is spending $250,000 to put the flames on show.

Visitors will be able to get close to the roaring flames, which will be encased in a steel and glass structure at the centre.

To create 'Tornado', which will go on show in early November, about 3 litres of kerosene will be placed in the central shallow pan. Once lit, 24 slanted vents around the base channel in cool air.

As the cool air rushes in at an angle to replace the rising hot air, a swirl of air currents is created, spinning the flame into a spiralling column in the tower.

The column, which can reach a width of about 1m and a temperature of 300 to 600 deg C, will burn for three to five minutes. There will be bubbles released into the column to demonstrate the air flow, and Dr Tsai has also developed technology for the creation of hydrogen bubbles which will crackle when they burst, adding another dimension to the show.

However, before it can go on display, the exhibit must get safety approval from Singapore Civil Defence Force fire chiefs.

'It will be the iconic, awe-inspiring attraction of the fire exhibition,' said Dr Tsai, who took about four months to build the device. The fire exhibition will include a look at the impact of fire on human civilisation, and the use of fire in domestic and industrial settings.

The Science Centre has filed a patent for a smaller prototype of his invention, at a cost of about $10,000. Patenting an exhibit idea has not been done before at the centre, which is looking to sell tabletop versions of the device at its Jurong shop and other outlets, and hopes it will be as popular as lava lamps. 'I think it represents a milestone for the centre. Even though we may not patent everything, we want to recognise a good idea when it occurs,' said the centre's chief executive, Dr Chew Tuan Chiong.

The invention is believed to be the first flame tornado that does not have to rely on mechanics such as air jets and fans to generate the swirl.

Said Dr Tsai: 'I felt it in my bones, having spent years in aerodynamics, that there must be a way to do it better.'

VICTORIA VAUGHAN

Monday, July 27, 2009

Thio cancels NYU stint

July 27, 2009
Don lost the chance to field her arguments in marketplace of ideas

IN THE wake of Professor Thio Li-ann's decision not to teach at New York University (NYU), much as been made of a lack of tolerance of diverse views in that university. Both Prof Thio and Mr Eugene Tan from Singapore Management University have cited the sequence of events as a display of intolerance.

With respect to both the learned professors, I feel this is a mischaracterisation of what transpired at NYU. A right to express one's views freely comes with the right of others to disagree with those views, and one must take courage to defend what one believes in.

The NYU position throughout this unfortunate sequence of events has been that while the faculty may disagree with Prof Thio's position, it believes that academic freedom should be respected. Even when alumni threatened to boycott future fund-raising events unless Prof Thio was refused access, the university was steadfast in its position that it would not force Prof Thio to withdraw. �

It is disingenuous to paint the disagreement as a suppression of alternative views. Surely one cannot be naive to the fact that the attitude in the United States towards homosexuals is significantly different from that in Singapore. Just as Prof Thio was entitled to her view that homosexual acts should be criminalised, so were the NYU faculty and students entitled to their view that such discrimination is abhorrent.

In many ways, what happened at NYU has been disappointing. By cancelling her courses, Prof Thio has lost the chance to field her arguments in an open marketplace of ideas. The NYU students too have lost the opportunity to be taught by someone who, all views aside, is an extremely intelligent academic with a great presence in the classroom.�

Leon Michael Ryan


-----------------
July 27, 2009
Don's withdrawal from NYU: Don't be too quick to claim victimhood

I REFER to the reports, 'Thio Li-ann cancels teaching stint at NYU' (last Friday) and 'American social activist support Thio Li-ann' (last Saturday), regarding law professor Thio Lin-ann's withdrawal from her teaching stint at New York University (NYU).

The reports imply that Professor Thio felt she had to withdraw from NYU after she was intimidated by the hostile atmosphere there. This should be examined more closely.

At no point did NYU rescind its invitation to Prof Thio. Likewise, the gay university campaign group OUTLaw did not ask for her invitation to be withdrawn. It sent an e-mail message to students stating its position on her homosexual issues, with links to videos of speeches she made in Parliament in 2007. In OUTLaw's own words:

'While respecting Dr Thio's right to her opinion and without questioning her teaching abilities, OUTLaw believes it is important for LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) students and allies to be aware of her views in order to make fully informed decisions regarding class registration.'

There was also an online petition that expressed 'deep disappointment' at NYU's decision to appoint her as Global Visiting Professor of Law. The petition, which drew about 880 signatures, did state that the 'decision to appoint Dr Thio was a grave mistake and her designation to teach 'Human Rights in Asia' is inappropriate and offensive'. But there was no explicit call for her invitation to be rescinded.�

Prof�Thio�is quick to claim victimhood. But when�she accepted the invitation, she must have been aware that her views would not be popular at NYU, a famously liberal university. She should have been prepared for NYU undergraduates to express their opposition strongly.

Bert Wee
-----------------

NUANCE, A SO-CALLED MEMO AND THREATS ...
Letter from Professor Thio Li-ann
05:55 AM Jul 27, 2009

I WRITE to clarify a few points in "Former NMP calls off professorship at NYU"(July 24).

First, the online petition asserting I was an "opponent of human rights" over-simplistically assumes "gay rights are human rights".

Certain countries legally recognise the controversial idea of "gay rights", but this is not a universally accepted human right. Further, the idea of "gay rights" may cover anything from prohibiting workplace discrimination (which I support) to same-sex marriage (which I oppose).

Nuance is needed; simplification is sensationalistic.

Can a capitalist teach Marxism? Could someone who supports the death penalty (which many at New York University disagree with) teach human rights?

There is no settled theory of the source of human rights; many competing interpretations exist. There are core (prohibiting torture) and contested (same-sex marriage, euthanasia) rights.

Second, no 18-page rebuttal was sent to the NYU law faculty. I do not know who posted the so-called "18-point memo" circulating online. This was an internal email I wrote in response to a non-law NYU staffer's email copied to the Dean (who made no response) and others, strongly criticising my appointment.

This was just one of the hostile, often vulgar messages I received, some insulting my intellect, gender, ethnicity and country.

I sought to clarify misrepresentations and rebut potentially defamatory allegations made to personnel involved in the Global Faculty programme which invited my visit.

It is disappointing the NYU law dean would label my response "offensive" and "hurtful", while ignoring the offensive, hurtful and even threatening messages directed against me.

To say I was "disappointed by the hostility" minimises the virulence of the attacks I received. A cursory glance at the invective online explains why many friends worried for my safety.

An American NYU alumnus wrote to the NYU law dean (copied to me), saying he had the impression the dean was "not troubled by the kind of atmosphere" that I was "expected to endure" had I decided to teach at NYU.

Some NYU faculty, staff and students also sent supportive emails; a gay New Yorker apologised for the bullying tactics of certain activists who did not represent him.

Academic freedom dissipates in a hostile environment - by this I do not mean mere viewpoint disputation. Why prejudicially assume I would create "an unwelcoming atmosphere" in class, as opposed to politicking students or frosty faculty members?

Why assume I would not permit free discussion when it is "political correctness" which chills free debate? An email from a Harvard law graduate noted of this affair: "Things just got a little bit darker down at NYU.

-----------
Prof Thio,

"Nuance is needed. Oversimplification is sensationalistic." Very well said. You are a very capable, eloquent academic. Too bad I disagree with you about homosexuality.

The next time anyone says that homosexuality is "anti-family", please help us all tell them many gays can and do love their families a lot. Nuance is needed. Oversimplification is sensationalistic.

The next time anyone says gays are responsible for AIDS/HIV, please remind them the virus spreads because of promiscuity and unsafe sex, not because of a person's sexuality. Nuance is needed. Oversimplification is sensationalistic.

The next time someone equates supporting homosexuals as supporting incest, rape, infidelity, murder, animal sex, please help us all tell them those are wrongful, vulgar accusations. Nuance is needed. Oversimplification is sensationalistic.
Posted by: wugui1977 at Mon Jul 27 10:33:45 SGT 2009


Re-merger revisited - Response

July 27, 2009
S'pore in a far better position to survive independently

I REFER to last Saturday's letter by Mr K. Kalidas, 'Revisiting merger'.

Singapore was expelled from Malaysia in 1965, chiefly due to its uncompromising stance on giving equal treatment to people of all races. To put it simply, Singapore's sovereignty was born out of principles and confidence. After 44 years of independence, the considerable economic gap is one of the many testaments to what a nation with strong principles and confidence can achieve.

Like an abandoned child left to fend for itself in an uncongenial milieu, Singapore in 1965 held little hope in the minds of almost all pundits. Despite seemingly insurmountable odds, Singapore survived and grew considerably, and became nimble and tough.

In human achievement, no civilisation, nation or city has had infant mortality rate drop as quickly as in Singapore. One top of that, no country with such diverse demographics has achieved the racial and religious harmony of Singapore.

China, with one-fifth of the world population, is the world's fastest-growing major economy. At the current clip, it is set to be the largest economy in the world by 2050. The Chinese have enormous brainpower but still model their developing cities on Singapore. This cannot be a coincidence. It is a strong indicator that Singapore has moved in the right direction and implemented the right policies.

Despite shifts in geopolitical tectonic plates and economic fundamentals, the Singapore of 2009 is no doubt in a better position than the Singapore of 1965 to survive independently for the next century. The key is to keep institutionalising what works and never waver on the very principles that created Singapore.

Singapore did relatively well, precisely because it stuck to its principles with confidence. Unless Malaysia adopts the same principles, it can never pose a challenge to Singapore's independence. The Singaporean Narrative, to use the term coined by Professor Kishore Mahbubani, is not a mirage, but a real possibility.

Tay Xiong Sheng

Sunday, July 26, 2009

Revisiting merger

July 25, 2009
TIES WITH MALAYSIA

[Commenting along the way. Generally, I think it is good that we consider all possibilities and keep an open mind, but re-merger is highly unlikely, and I'll cover that at the end.]

IN HIS commentary on Wednesday, 'KL-Singapore ties: Turning of the tide', Mr K. Kesavapany seems to agree with his Malaysian friend Din Merican that Singapore is no longer dependent on the Malaysian hinterland for its economic prosperity as it is driven by financial and intellectual capital.

I tend to see things differently. The very economic fundamentals that required Singapore to join Malaysia may revisit us 30 to 40 years down the road for us to consider seriously the option of re-merger.

In the long term, the rise of China and India, the waning power of the United States, the European Union and Japan, and the concurrent economic development and prosperity of regional countries, including our neighbours Malaysia and Indonesia, will have serious implications for Singapore's survival.

Fifty years ago, Malaysia imported its Mandarin oranges, lychees and longans and other Chinese goods largely from Singapore, as Malaysia shunned direct import of China goods for political reasons. It is no longer so and this is one example where the tide has turned to Singapore's disadvantage.

[Economic fundamentals have changed vis-a-vis Singapore-Malaysia relationship. In the past, we took as a given the need for the "hinterland" of Malaysia. However, that position of M'sia can be seen (and is seen by Dr M) as insulting. No country would enjoy being labeled as any other country's "hinterland". So yes, we don't re-export Chinese goods to M'sia because situations change. But Singapore changes with it.

We move into higher value added products, like wafer fabrication which is a water-heavy industry. M'sia followed us and competed with us, but they wanted an additional advantage, so they tried to up the price of the water they were selling us to ridiculous rates. We went the NEWater route and we aren't looking back.]

The rising prosperity of regional countries will drive our imported talent back to their home countries and beyond, where good jobs await them in plenty, including thousands of Malaysians who make up a critical segment of our manpower.

[Certainly, there may be a pull back to the home country. But it is not just good jobs awaiting that will pull people back. Singapore's attraction is not just our prosperity, but how we create this prosperity and the opportunities Singapore can offer both in terms of career but also as a place to live and raise a family. ]

Also as these countries replicate Singapore's work efficiency, organisation and training of labour in higher skills, they will no longer need Singapore as a trading and service hub to conduct their cross-border business transactions. The reality is no country, big or small, however close and supportive of us they may be now, owes us a living.

[And we have never operated on "the world owes us a living" presumption. Everything we get, we paid for or reimbursed with comparable value. Cheap raw water from M'sia? In exchange we provided subsidised treated water so needed that M'sia drew much more than their allowance in the water agreement. On the other hand, M'sia seems to think that we owe them something. This is historical emotional baggage that will not fade away so easily.]

Did Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew's recent visit to Malaysia - undertaken primarily to lay the ground work for second-tier leaders in both countries to get to know each other better and forge stronger ties - also imply a long-term view of possible re-merger as an option that should not be ruled out?

MM Lee said in 2007: 'If they (Malaysia) would just educate the Chinese and Indians, use them and treat them as their citizens, they can equal us and even do better than us and we would be happy to rejoin them.'

[You may wish to read "re-merger" in that. But I wouldn't. MM Lee is a pragmatist. The meritocracy principle will be a non-negotiable for Singapore. But in Bumi M'sia, that is still a long way away. And if M'sia does surpass Singapore, what benefits would there be for M'sia? Would it not be better to keep Singapore separate and independent and an example to trot out every now and then to show how far M'sia has come? They don't owe us a living if they ever surpass us. Can we rejoin M'sia as equals? I don't think so. As a vessal? That was the plan 44 years ago, but it may not be relevant. However for historical closure M'sia might take us back as a humbled vessal. But it would not be to our advantage.]

It is important that non-Malay Singaporeans learn the Malay language. Forty years ago, most Chinese stall keepers spoke a smattering of Malay, but now it is an alien language. The Government should encourage learning Malay on a wider scale.

K. Kalidas

[And then an agenda from left field. In the long term view of history, anything is possible and remerger cannot be ruled out. But, we can consider situations where remerger would not occur. The following scenarios does not consider how likely it would happen, just merely what if it happened - would merger be probable?

Situation 1. Singapore strong, M'sia relatively weaker.
I would say that this is the current situation. In such a situation, Singapore would gain nothing from merger. If Singapore wre were still dependent on primary industry, perhaps. If merger happens it would have to be on Singapore's terms, and it is unlikely that M'sia would swallow its pride and accede to Singapore's terms. No matter how bad the situation. And it is also unlikely that Singapore would want to be responsible for M'sia. That would be too big a job.

Situation 2. M'sia ascendent, Singapore relatively weaker or in decline.
Here the tables are turned. Singapore has no natural resources to speak of. M'sia would have little reason to merge with Singapore. The S'pore Chinese would probably not be very amenable to M'sia's political system and taking in Singapore would be like letting a viper into your house. There would be little material or political gain from merger (from the M'sian perspective) and more risk than is necessary. M'sia would probably do better by letting Singapore get weaker, use Singapore as an example of a weak neighbour, and maybe offer some humanitarian help now and then to gain moral superiority. If M'sia succeeds without Singapore, it makes no economic sense to bring in a weakened Singapore. We would only be a liability and a risk.

Situation 3. S'pore & M'sia equally or comparatively strong economically.
Negotiating from strength sounds more plausible. However if the political and philosophical gulfs that led to Separation in 1965 are still there, there would be little reason to merge as the reasons for separation still exists. Thus S'pore & M'sia may be strong economically but each is strong for different reasons. In any case if each has succeeded without the other, the question would be what synergy would a merger bring and at what costs? S'pore would never go the bumiputra route and would never accept it. While I believe that for as long as M'sia has the Bumi policy they can never be as competitive or efficient, this scenario assumes that they succeed with or in spite of the Bumi policy. Okay, what if M'sia had set aside the Bumi policy (which the current PM is starting to do, but given the tendency for M'sia to u-turn their policy...)? There would be no barriers (from the Singapore perspective) to re-merger, but there are no push or pull factors to encourage merger. When Singapore merged 46 years ago, it was to break away from the Brits for independence. There is no such push now. Singapore is already independent and in this scenario, it is doing fine. Similarly, M'sia has no push factor to seek re-merger other than a Malay hegemony, which would be tied to Malay dominance or supremacy, which means that M'sia would not have abandoned the bumi policy.

Situation 4: S'pore & M'sia both weakened and in decline.
Merger here must be seen as a win-win synergistic solution to both countries fighting for survival.  But it may not be so. In times of trouble, doors tend to close. it would take visionary leaders on both sides of the causeway to see a way forward that ties the destiny of two poor countries together. ]


Friday, July 24, 2009

In (limited) defence of like-minded enclaves

July 24, 2009

I THANK Ms Lydia Lim for her column last Friday, 'Beware enclaves of the like-minded', which highlighted the difference between 'religiosity per se' and 'religious practices that lead to closed communities'. I am glad she warned against an unqualified 'flight to uniformity'.

However, her point was made at the expense of 'like-minded enclaves', and it would be equally disastrous if Singapore ended end up distrusting any and every group's deeply held, faithfully practised convictions.

There is another, better way to build healthy communities, and it lies in good, old-fashioned communication and the careful instruction of Singaporeans, beginning with clarifying our thoughts and public writing on this subject.

While I share Ms Lim and Minister in the Prime Minister's Office Lim Boon Heng's concern regarding closed communities, care needs to be exercised in defining 'closed'. In a necessary and very real sense, every cogent belief or thought system rules out ideas that are antithetical to or incompatible with it. This is simply how we define who we are and what we believe - by drawing boundaries.

These demarcations are not inherently harmful. 'Good fences make good neighbours', so the late American poet laureate Robert Frost perceptively penned. As Ms Lim rightly notes, any community trades on its simultaneous openness and 'closedness' within the larger society. The enclaves per se are not the problem; to speak of integration is meaningless if there are no pre-existing differences.

Nor should we move to eradicate all those differences - that would be a flight to homogeneity.

What we must avoid is segregation, the 'closedness', not of healthy communities within a society, but of isolation without participation in the greater whole.

So how do we build communities that reach out beyond the very fences that construct and contain them? Again, the fences should not be mistaken as the problem. Rather than discourage people from believing anything too deeply or from disbanding their support groups, we should encourage and value communication and understanding across these social groups.

We must surely learn to recognise and accept our differences, and still choose to interact with one another; this should not exclude having the support of a like-minded group. To return to the proverb 'Good fences make good neighbours', well, we can value our neighbours, as neighbours - but they do not live in our homes. Nor should they have to, to be valued.

It is worth spelling this out in our public discussions because the word 'tolerance' has shifted in meaning in recent years (especially in terms like religious tolerance), largely because of the influence of political correctness in the United States and elsewhere. It used to be that tolerance meant putting up with someone else's point of view and recognising that he was entitled to express it, even if one had an entirely different point of view.

Today, tolerance seems to mean never really expressing your view because that in itself impinges on someone else's perceived right not to be discomfited by it; and that is a shame.

Such tolerance is more likely to produce segregation than the sensitive practice of entrenched beliefs. For where would the interaction between those beliefs be if no one is voicing true convictions? Where is the 'multi' part of our multi-religious national identity?

Are the common bonds of our nationhood so superficial that we cannot express deeply held religious beliefs in a climate that can agree to disagree?

How much in-depth understanding of others can we ever have if the only beliefs - spiritual, intellectual, emotional or otherwise - we can share or bear to hear from others are watered down and of the lowest common denominator? How then to develop our own minds or form our own opinions? Is it any wonder we are constantly lamenting the state of this nation?

And so, finally, in the interest of genuine understanding, on to the example Ms Lim gave: the worrisome 41.5 per cent of Christian clergymen who would resist the perception that all religions are equal. In fact, many mainstream Christian groups do not accept that all religions are right and the same. Those clergymen are only being faithful leaders. They are neither against charity nor against dialogue.

Ms Lim, Mr Lim and others would be less worried if they understood also that the unique calling of these Christian clergymen makes them more, not less, responsible for and thoughtful about their interaction with larger society, including other religious groups, the authorities and the law of the land. The label 'closed' or 'exclusivist' is unhelpful and misleading for a religion just as deeply committed to reaching out and engaging with the unlike.

Religious devotion is not in itself a threat to social cohesion. I think we can also agree that we are talking about social responsibility in exercising those personal beliefs. If so, let us carefully define and adequately address such things as communication, tolerance (old style) and unity in diversity.

Do not demonise 'likeminded enclaves' and inadvertently fuel the misguided notion that harmony and unity are about never being deeply committed to local causes or never hearing or expressing viewpoints different to one's own. What we need in a climate of weakening social bonds (if that is the perceived fear) is greater, not less, understanding of those around us.

Karen Kwek (Ms)

[This is generally a well-argued and well-presented position. I can agree that groups need boundaries for their identity. And every community can be both closed and open.

And yes I agree that a more tolerant definition of "tolerance" would be nicer, but the agenda of the aggressively evangelistic is suspect. One comment on-line:

Being an ex-christian, I can agree with Karen kwek that the Christian religion is deeply committed to reaching out, but it's mostly the kind of 'reaching out' the others are afraid of - trying to convert someone else relentlessly like a hardcore salesman, even after the potential 'victim' says 'not interested'.

'Reaching out' as in telling others what you believe is fine. It is the 'reaching out' as in trying relentlessly to convert( eg. waiting at the school gates to distribute religious literature and stopping students from leaving until they take a copy or give their phone numbers) that's unsettling.

Posted by: GhostRider666 at Fri Jul 24 22:15:57 SGT 2009

Karen also asks, "can we not agree to disagree?" Yes we can. But the aggressively evangelistic cannot.

In fact, "many mainstream Christian groups do not accept that all religions are right and the same."

If so, can we agree to disagree and not talk about how Christians disagree with other religions? Because what would be the point? To realise we disagree? Or to realise how much we disagree?

For as long as aggressive evangelists treat their religion as some divine MLM or pyramid scheme, there can be no tolerance at the level of open discourse leading to agreeing to disagree.

Karen speaks of "greater understanding of those around us". Perhaps she should put her money where her mouth is. What steps has she taken to understand another faith? Or is her understanding of "understanding" purely one way? That non-christians should understand why Christianity is the one true religion.

Here's a deeper understanding of multi-religious Singapore. If one religion aggressively converts the followers of another, understand that the other religion will not stand idly by with passive "tolerance". They will fight for their followers, and the survival of their faith.

What's so "multi" about multi-religious Singapore? It is that the religions co-exist without attempting to wipe each other out either with violence or more subtly by systematic conversion of followers of other religions. Maybe that's a superficial definition of "harmony", but it beats a situation of religious antagonism/aggression.

The reality of Singapore (and most places) is that harmony is achieved by respecting boundaries (Karen's quoting Frost - "good fences"). Championing some idealistic notion of tolerance and free discourse while ignoring the effect of such idealism is naive, irresponsible and dangerous.

Eventually, it may be safer to ban all cults that pursue evangelisation as a core duty of its members.]

[Edited May 1, 2010. Further comments:
Enclaves of the like-minded exists in politics as well, and the two-party Democrats-Republicans system in the US is a prime example and model of what extremes such enclaves can go to. When you surround yourself with like-minded people, speak only to like-minded people, share your frustrations (with contrary views and people with those views) with like-minded people who express support for your grief and anguish and reinforce your worldview, your views and position will become more entrenched, more polarised, and more rooted. There are websites, radio, and other media channels that support and reinforce these enclaves of the like-minded, and being immersed daily in such an environment serves to close one mind to all other possibilities.

Free discourse works when the ideas being presented are more fact-based than faith-based. The scientific community can engage in free discourse because positions can be proven or disproven, evidence can be presented, examined, discredited, or accepted.

With faith and conviction, all you have are bold statements, subjective interpretations, followed by a lot of singing, or chanting, or yelling. Free discourse does not work in matters of faith and personal convictions. ]

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Moral values & Terrorism

July 21, 2009
Let's reinforce unity of purpose in fighting terrorism

WE CAN never overemphasise the need to remain vigilant against the threat of terrorism, as warned by Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong in last Sunday's report, 'PM Lee warns of evolving terror threat'.

He warned that the recent bomb explosions at the Ritz-Carlton and JW Marriott hotels in Jakarta showed that terrorists continue to have 'new ways of doing evil, bad deeds'. Schools, religious organisations and the business community need to make a concerted effort to not only condemn the murderous acts of terrorism, but also set the boundaries that define good and evil in society.

Often, the human spirit needs to be rekindled to distinguish between right and wrong behaviour. Religions with good society and family values must take proactive steps to engage the public and schools by upholding godly values and renouncing the evil that destroys the fabric of society. Our children need to learn from religious leaders who demonstrate how their faith can build strong family bonds and create social stability, harmony and security. Where the fault lines of society are shaken, religious leaders are to super-glue the gaps.

Religious leaders in collaboration with the Government should openly reject socially irresponsible behaviour such as racism, religious intolerance, adultery as well as perverse sexual behaviour in society. Moral relativism has no place in a society that treasures and thrives on good, absolute values.

As part of civil defence, schools must be vigilant to teach children strong traditional family values through the covenant of marriage and fidelity to one's spouse.

Insidious and egregious practices such as abuse of human rights and extreme liberalism must be exposed and rejected for what they are. Drug trafficking, use of abortion as a form of contraceptive, polygamy and serial divorce will remain as wrongdoings. Our police force should be held in high regard as they enforce the rules against criminal behaviour.

Children must be encouraged to speak up against evil and not fear being rebuked for doing the right thing. The heathen attack religious people with the phrase: 'Get down from your high horse for we reject your holier-than-thou attitude.'

Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew recently remarked that for 44 years, Singapore still has not yet achieved the ideals of nationhood. Perhaps the next step requires the conviction and partnership of religious and government leaders to take a firm stand against wicked deeds and support those who stand for the truth in nation building. It is time we took serious heed of the axiom: 'Righteousness exalts a nation.'

George Lim

July 22, 2009
Poor logic to equate terrorism with lifestyle decisions

I WRITE in response to Mr George Lim's Forum Online letter on Monday, "Let's reinforce unity of purpose in fighting terrorism".

Mr Lim is correct to label the Jakarta bombings as evil and murderous. But he is wrong when he goes on to argue that for Singapore to achieve social security, harmony and stability, "strong family bonds" and "traditional family values through the covenant of marriage" must be upheld. Accordingly, pre-marital sex, abortion, serial divorce and "perverse sexual behaviour", such as homosexuality, must be condemned.

It is poor logic to equate terror attacks to personal decisions such as homosexuality and serial divorce. These actions involve only willing parties and do no harm to others.

On the other hand, crimes like terrorism, murder and robbery involve the harm (and possible deaths) of other innocent parties. Rightfully, divorce, pre-martial sex and abortion are not punishable by the common law, which serves mainly to protect the fellow man. Countries such as the United States and France, while having astronomical divorce and pre-martial sex rates, are still prosperous and socially cohesive.

Mr Lim also argues that Singapore's government should partner religious leaders to take a firm stand against evil, heathen and non-godly values.

If this is so, then a good number of Singaporeans will run afoul of the rules simply on the basis that they do not believe in godly values, but answer responsibly to their conscience.

Many Singaporeans, while expressing faith in religion, also see no wrong in pre-marital sex, homosexuality and abortion, because these are matters of personal choice.

Surely atheists, agnostics and liberal followers of religion deserve the right to live unharassed by the beliefs of the staunchly religious.

Jonathan Kwok Dao Yang
-------
I quote what George Lim mentioned in his letter on Monday.

"schools must be vigilant to teach children strong traditional family values through the covenant of marriage and fidelity to one's spouse."

I'm sure Rodney Sim, and ELDER from LIGHTHOUSE EVANGELISM CHURCH - the man paid for sex with an underaged teen as mentioned in today's paper must have had really strong family values (he has 2 kids mind you). So strong that he couldn't resist having sex with a Chinese child prostitute. Well done you over-religious, self-righteous morons.

Terrorism came about because of these religious fanatics, and all George Lim's letter did was to self contradict himself.
Posted by: urbanator at Wed Jul 22 10:28:38 SGT 2009

-------
Jonathan old boy! I think you are missing the gist of what George is trying to say. George is merely inferring that if you get the basics right from the onset, perhaps people would not think of turning to terrorism or aggression for whatever reason. And he goes on to mention that religion and the government by working in collaboration on certain issues with youngsters might ultimately create a more upright person thus deferring anyone from going as far as thinking of resorting to aggression of any sort. Whether this will help or not is the question, but certainly there is some basis to what he is saying. After all if you are generally an organized person, the tendency is you will be neat and tidy in appearance and vice versa. Positivity begets positivity, negativity begets negativity get it. So don’t take his words out of context. But when it comes to certain beliefs, I think George is indulging in a bit of wishful thinking, he is like many others who believe all religions are the same, teach peace, love etc. Well he has another guess coming.

And urbanator old chap. Rodney Sim is a hypocrite like many other religious goons, and despite his religious foundation, he failed miserably and is certainly a perfect example that Christians are not perfect, but at least he did not resort to violence. His beliefs ultimately kicked in and he resorted to redeem himself by helping the girl and getting himself into trouble with the law while at it. This is somewhat what George is getting at. So save the rhetoric for yourself.
Posted by: ontheside at Wed Jul 22 12:22:55 SGT 2009

-----------
Hi ontheside,

I shall quote ad verbatim Mr George's letter:

Schools, religious organisations and the business community need to make a concerted effort to not only condemn the murderous acts of terrorism, but also set the boundaries that define good and evil in society.

Often, the human spirit needs to be rekindled to distinguish between right and wrong behaviour. Religions with good society and family values must take proactive steps to engage the public and schools by upholding godly values and renouncing the evil that destroys the fabric of society.
--------

He surely did not hint, or argue, that a 'morally decadent society' will lead eventually to terrorist acts, or that a more upright person may resort to aggression.

His argument, plainly, is to argue that schools, governments, businesses etc should combat 'evil' in society as much as they combat terrorist tendencies. His definition of 'evil', as we have seen, is very narrow, and includes all sorts of behaviour that many people consider very normal.

Why should people combat 'evil' (George's definition of evil) with as much vigour as they combat terrorism? They are miles apart. How can they be equated?
Posted by: jonkwok at Wed Jul 22 16:07:41 SGT 2009

-------
July 22, 2009
Man jailed, fined for paid sex with teen

His attempts to help her after she said she was forced into prostitution led to a police report

By Elena Chong

AN ACCOUNTANT who twice paid to have sex with an underage prostitute from China was jailed for two weeks and fined $16,000 yesterday.

The sentence amounted to a victory of sorts for Rodney Sim Hang Nge, 61, who had testified that he did not know the girl was 16 when he had sex with her.

He could have been jailed up to seven years, or fined a maximum of $10,000 on each charge - or both - under a new law, which makes it a crime to have paid sex with a person under 18. The law took effect in February last year.

The father of two grown-up children, a daughter and a son, pleaded guilty last December to two counts of paying $100 to have sex with the girl on Aug 3 and 5 last year.

But during his sentencing hearing, he disputed the prosecution's contention that he knew the prostitute was underage.

Another hearing was then held to resolve this.

Yesterday, District Judge Jeffrey Sim ruled that Sim, an elder at the Lighthouse Evangelism church, did not deliberately exploit a minor. 'He was misled by both the pimp and the minor into believing that the minor was 18 or above 18 years old,' the judge said.

Sim, he said, also tried to help the prostitute after she told him that she was being forced to work as a commercial sex worker against her will.

In fact, his attempts to help her landed him in hot water.

He took her to the Chinese Embassy and then to a police post to lodge a report, and this led to charges against him.

The judge said these facts made Sim's case different from that of Tan Chye Hin, 55, who was jailed nine months last year for having sex with the same girl.

The renovation contractor, who was the first person convicted under the revised law, knew the girl was a minor and had specifically sought her sexual services.

However, despite the differences in the two cases, the judge dismissed a plea from Sim's lawyers, Mr Shashi Nathan and Ms Tania Chin, for a fine to be imposed.

Judge Sim said a fine alone would not be appropriate, as the law was enacted to protect the vulnerable group of under-18 minors from being sexually exploited.

Sim, he added, should have insisted on verifying the girl's age from her passport before engaging her services, instead of relying on the bare representations of the pimp and the minor.

elena@sph.com.sg