Monday, January 25, 2010

Sorry, Fill My Cups event was a play on DJ's moniker

Jan 25, 2010

I REFER to last Thursday's letter, 'Wrong to promote women as sex objects', by the Association of Women for Action and Research (Aware), on its displeasure over the Fill My Cups promotion held at OverEasy bar on Jan 16.

The party was primarily a guest DJ event that originated as a play on the DJ's name, DCUP. It was never our intention to create an event to, in any way, diminish or denigrate women but a tongue-in-cheek play on the DJ's moniker.

The women who participated came dressed as they pleased, whether clad in a tank top or turtleneck, and were visually assessed by four individuals behind a booth, three of whom were women. None of the women was turned away because she did not meet any set standards and all who participated (regardless of size) received the promised privilege.

Upcoming events intend to reward customers who possess the biggest biceps, the smallest shoe size and the longest hands. As with this promotion, we hope these will not be viewed through a discriminatory lens but rather seen as a celebration of individuality and uniqueness.

In the light of Aware's comments, The Lo & Behold Group sincerely apologises to all who were offended by the event. We fully understand the relevance of Aware's contentions and can see how our intentions could have been easily misconstrued.

Aware suggests that choices should be made based on a particular social context. We feel that such context is an individual preference and that people should not be made to feel guilty for making their own choices.

We hope Aware will extend to us the tolerance to express ourselves in ways different from its own ways, to be able to laugh at ourselves once in a while and not be too quick to shade this event in a discriminatory light.

As an alternative to Aware's view, we believe society has evolved sufficiently to look beyond equating a woman's assets as sex objects. Furthermore, we believe that recognition of one's physical assets does not detract from an individual's ability to gain respect through other attributes.

We respect Aware's opinion, but it is more important not to undermine the patrons who chose to participate in the event. They are modern, confident individuals who know their place in society and that their self-worth is not based solely on their 'assets'. We respect and stand by them.

Cheryl Ho (Miss)
Spokesman for The Lo & Behold Group

[Bravo! This is an example of a great response to a petty knee-jerk complaint. The reply was intelligent, respectful, but also showed self-respect for the programme as well as for the women who participated in their promotion. In acknowledging AWARE's opinion, it did not betray their customers. And finally, Miss Ho (not Ms) signed off as the "Spokesman" not Spokesperson, or Spokeswoman. Bravo!]

Thursday, January 21, 2010

WORLD CUP - Broadcast rights for Singapore

Jan 21, 2010
FIFA'S OUTRAGEOUS WORLD CUP FEE

Blame SingTel's EPL gambit

YESTERDAY'S report ('World Cup fans may miss out on all matches') indicates that Singapore will be denied the live telecast of this year's football World Cup because SingTel and StarHub will not pay the price demanded by soccer's world governing body, Fifa.

The self-destructive contest between SingTel and StarHub for the telecast rights to the English Premier League (EPL) played into Fifa's hands.

As we can afford the exorbitant price for EPL rights, why not for World Cup 2010, Fifa must have reasoned - a hard-nosed stance which is not consonant with its fair-play motto.

SingTel and StarHub say they must balance the interests of their shareholders against the passion of football-crazy Singaporeans. If that is so, how can SingTel justify its pyrrhic win of EPL rights?

It appears to have learnt an expensive lesson. The Government so far looks askance at the issue; it appears aloof to the angst of many Singaporeans.

[Right. The Govt should step in to solve this "Problem". $100m so that Singaporeans can watch football. The WORLD Cup!!! The problems of the unemployed, the homeless, the poor is NOTHING compared to the angst of the middle class football fanatics.]

If Singapore had qualified to play in South Africa (an ambitious target mooted many years ago by then Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong), would the Government not have used its influence with internal and external parties to ensure we got to watch the national side play? A case can be argued for the Media Development Authority to deploy a portion of its TV licence fee - which is meant to fund public service programmes, we are repeatedly told whenever the continuing need for the fee is challenged - to help in this impasse.

[What about those people who don't watch football? Should their licence be used to pay for the wants of others? $110 per year per household. At about 1 million households, the FIFA fees would wipe out the TV license revenue. It would not be a portion. Or it would be so large a portion, there would be little left for anything else.]

What about Singapore Pools, which rakes in handsome profits from football bets? Surely its takings will be badly hurt without the live telecast. People, including policymakers, with scant interest in football will not understand the furore. Why give in to extortion, they may ask. But to many ordinary Singaporeans, it is no trivial matter.

[Singapore Pools exists to manage the need/want of people to gamble. They should not encourage gambling, merely offer an outlet for legal (i.e. taxed and controlled by the govt) gambling.]

The travesty is that many poor countries will get to watch the matches live for a token fee: An admirable bit of social work by Fifa.

But Singapore, so affluent and regarded by some as punching above its weight on various matters, must pay the price in all senses. Will we? Should we?

Tan Chak Lim

[Well, Singaporeans can go to neighbouring countries for World Cup Holidays. might be cheaper, and it would help tourism in our neighbours. All this panic over nothing. Yes, Fifa will try to squueze what they think Singapore can afford. But they have a fixed cost. And that is covered by now by all the deals struck. Singapore can either be a $100m revenue or a $15m revenue but it doesn't costs FIFA much more to sell the rights to Singapore. If they can't get $100m, they should be able to settle - maybe $50m. It's better than no deal or $0 if they can't settle. And if they don't, Singapore will go on. It won't kill us.]

MR VICTOR KHOO: 'Isn't it a shame that Singapore can host the Formula One night races and have two integrated resorts but cannot broadcast the world's most popular sports spectacle, the World Cup, which takes place only once in four years? It is obvious that Fifa chose to charge the reported $100 million for this year's World Cup television rights simply because it thinks Singapore is extravagantly wealthy. SingTel's massive $400 million bid for the English Premiership rights must have figured in Fifa's perception. The Media Development Authority (MDA) wants to stay out of the fray, citing commercialism, while government-owned Singapore Pools sidesteps potential involvement by saying broadcasting is not its business. What MDA must recognise is that football is a national passion, and it should be responsible enough to help find an answer and not wash its hands of the issue. And Singapore Pools must not forget that one of its key aims is to promote sports. Besides, sports betting is one of its revenue streams. Pools owes it to its loyal punters to help resolve the impasse.'

[Pools aim to promote sports? I think the writer mistook "pools" for swimming pools.]

Sunday, November 22, 2009

'Consent' shouldn't trump what society deems morally bad

Nov 23, 2009

I REFER to Mr Alvin Chen's letter last Monday, 'Give courts more sentencing discretion'. This was in response to Mr Vikram Ranjan Ramasamy's letter, 'Decriminalise consensual underage sex' (Nov 13).

Allowing 'consent' to trump what society perceives as morally bad behaviour is to undermine society's right to enforce its moral determinations. This was an issue that Lord Patrick Devlin addressed his mind to in his essay, The Enforcement Of Morals.

Lord Devlin stated that a shared morality is what keeps a society together. The law is used to prevent the loosening of this moral 'cement'. Thus, as a matter of presumption, the fact that a law exists that criminalises consensual sex between minors indicates that the word is already out on the moral judgment of such behaviour.

Mr Chen's argument that the state should be paternalistic in situations where consent might be given by minors who do not have sufficient maturity is also not without problems. First, using a 'sufficiently mature' consent approach to determine whether certain acts should be legislated is a slippery slope that could see us spiralling towards decriminalising even euthanasia or incest.

Second, Mr Chen's proposal of reform at the level of sentencing, and not at the level of legislation, presupposes that such an action is wrong to begin with. However, if Mr Chen is willing to accept it is not morally wrong for mature minors to engage in consensual sex, why should even punishment be meted out?

Alternatively, if one can show that as a matter of statistical probability, sexual activity at this age results in an aversion to deepening the commitment of a relationship via the institution of marriage, or that it affects an individual's psyche in the perception of the value of commitment, then in so far as the institution of marriage or the value of commitment is regarded as a moral good that society embraces, one could also find oneself somewhat persuaded that the law should remain.

Marcus Foo

[Agree with the gist of the letter. But Marcus makes a wrong assumption: that laws reflect morality. Adultery is morally unacceptable to most. But it is not criminalised. Prostitution is also not acceptable to most. But it is not criminalised. Gambling - to many also not acceptable, legal.

What "consenting" children do sexually is not morally acceptable. The question is whether criminalising these acts is the best solution? Sending them through the courts and giving the courts little discretionary powers to deal with minors - is this the best way to deal with the problem? The answer is not simply decriminalise or criminalise. A first step would be to give the courts more leeway and discretion.]

Thank you MM Lee, for showing the way

Nov 23, 2009

I HAVE always been impressed with Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew for his vision and passion. But my respect for him has gone up a few more notches after his recent speech to encourage the study of Chinese language differently.

Having believed earlier that every child can master two languages equally well, he admitted his mistake. He said he did not realise that a child's intelligence and language ability were two different things.

These are the lessons I have learnt from MM Lee:

# Leaders make policy for their country, not for themselves: The implementation of the bilingual policy was for the sake of the country. He envisioned the growth of China and he has been proven right. Now he is championing a change of course for the sake of Singapore citizens.

# Leaders admit mistakes: For a man of his stature, and one who has accomplished so much, he is willing to admit he was wrong. For that, I have the utmost respect.

# Leaders learn from their mistakes and make amends: MM Lee said: 'I intervened successively over the years and insisted that my experience should guide the policy. I was taking risks. I started wrong and I put it right.'

# Leaders acknowledge they may not have it right completely: MM Lee's willingness to learn, relearn and unlearn is truly admirable. Regarding the policy, he said: 'It is not completely right but I will get it right if I live long enough.' His keeping on pushing the boundary and passionately desiring to make a difference tops it all.

Thank you, MM Lee, for teaching me how to lead.

Dr John Ng


Saturday, September 19, 2009

Why living with parents is a stultifying Singaporean trait

Sep 19, 2009

I REFER to the replies which criticised my letter, 'Few babies? It's the Hotel Mama mindset' (Sept 9).

Let me emphasise that there are many reasons for a low fertility rate and that the situation in the West is similar to Singapore's.

But being forced to live with one's parents is something uniquely Singaporean, which has some negative consequences.

Human development goes through stages. To become an adult, not just in years, but in the truest sense of the word, one has to 'leave the dependency of childhood and adolescence...explore a variety of possible life directions in love, work and world views...before entering the enduring responsibilities that are normative in adulthood' (Wikipedia, Emerging adulthood).

Staying at home in one's 20s and early 30s keeps individuals dependent on the services of their parents (shelter, food, laundry and cleaning) and prevents them from proceeding in their personal development in some areas. Perhaps a psychologist could explain why facing challenges on our own and becoming independent is so important to our development?

My guess is that 50 years ago, people in Singapore got independent earlier, that the parent generation had to stand on their own feet and reached 'maturity' at an age when their children nowadays still enjoy the comfort of their parents' home.

In Switzerland, I had a neighbour who lived with his mother until she died when he was 60. Of course, he remained single for the rest of his life.

I grew up with my grandmother sharing our home, as my sister's family does now with my parents. But my sister had her own household before and lived in the United States and Japan for many years. Taking care of one's parents is a value cherished around the world, but it does not mean one should depend on one's parents long into adulthood.

I have a friend in Singapore who hates his father. Some years ago, when his mother got sick, the father refused to come back from Vietnam, where he worked. When she was terminally ill, he had to come back, but refused to pay for her treatment, sending his money to Vietnam instead, insisting it was his money.

His wife died and not long after he got involved with a woman 30 years younger, who wanted to marry him. But he had to prove his sincerity. So the father, who had just retired, gave her all his Central Provident Fund savings, upon which she disappeared.

My friend is so angry with his stubborn, selfish father who would not listen to reason. When my friend is at home, he locks his door and avoids seeing his father at all costs. But my friend is stuck with him in the same HDB flat.

Another friend in his early 30s goes to his room around 11pm and waits until his parents are asleep. Sneaking out, he locks his bedroom door so his parents think he is still asleep when they get up early in the morning, while he spends the night in a cheap hotel with a girl.

But I have another friend whose father got too sick to work. The son supports his parents and lives with them happily, with his wife and their first baby.

If someone wants to take care of his parents out of his free will and lives with them, I would be the first to applaud him for that. But filial piety should not be confused with the many who have no choice than to stay with their parents and where the parents support their adult children instead the other way round. This might feel comfortable, but for some it becomes so comfortable that they will never break free and start a family on their own, like my neighbour in Switzerland.

I am convinced that Singapore would benefit if it gave young adults a chance to live on their own. Singapore's population is supposed to grow to six million people, which means nearly 50 per cent more housing is needed. If that is possible, why not a small 10 per cent increase to cater for the needs of the young?

Peter Huber

---------- Online comment ---------

Hi all,

Stop critisizing Peter Huber for a moment and read his letter again. Peter is in fact pointing the finger at our govt for the lack of housing. This housing shortage (which leads to high property prices) will only worsen if PAP really goes for 6 million population!!!
Posted by: legolass at Sun Sep 20 00:13:01 SGT 2009

[Peter is rambling all over the place and drawing on any and all anecdotes to support his argument that children shouldn't live with their parents - for the sake of the children's psychological development and health. And if legolass is correct about his real point, she (and he) is missing the big picture. If 200,000 singles were suddenly free to buy their own flats under HDB rules, their entry into the market is going to increase demand and increase prices, not reduce them. And when Peter finally finds someone who will marry him, he will find that he and his wife will be competing with so many singles looking for a flat and prices will be even higher. Then he will be writing to the press to say why HDB should give priority to newly weds like him so that they can produce the children that Singapore wants and needs. He's not arguing from principle. He's arguing from self-interests and trying to disguise it as high principles. And even if he were arguing from high principles, then he needs to propose a solution that takes into account the real and local constraints. Otherwise, he's just a whiny impatient brat.]

Friday, September 18, 2009

ADORABLE WAY OF SPEAKING - Ris Low & her RazorTV interview

19 Sep 2009

I think the way Ms Low speaks is adorable. She really 'shouts me'. It is Singlish of the highest order and I lurve it.

Yes, we can make fun of Singlish for its peculiar pronunciation and queer sentence structure but it is our own self-evolved lingua franca.

The Speak Good English Movement chairman Goh Eck Keng is right. When we laugh at Ms Low, we are laughing at half of Singapore (maybe more).

I used to lament that we had no sense of language identity. Travelling around Asia, I have observed that every country has its unifying patois. The Thais speak Thai, Malaysians speak Malay tinged with English pronouns, the Indonesians have Bahasa and Filipinos have Tagalog.

We had nothing until Singlish came along.

Let's rejoice. Just as the Chinese have Chingrish and the Japanese have Japlish, we can take great pride in having our own Singlish.

And like any other language, it will evolve. You cannot stop it because this is the language of comfort and convenience.

We feel good when we hear it. It is warm, witty, humorous and musical. And it has such wonderful words.

Just the other day, I heard a Singapore Airlines stewardess say: 'Thankchew for frying with Sinkapor Allies, a member of Style Lions.'

What on earth was that? I had to think for a few seconds before connecting the dots. 'Style Lions' is 'Star Alliance'. But what a great name - Style Lions!

As for Ms Low, she is just gorgeous and 'Boomz', whether or not she wears a 'piss of rad bigini' or 'duck gins with leopard and zibbra preens'.

If she needs a dress that 'shouts' her for the big occasion, I offer to buy her one and I will get my cousin Tina Tan-Leo (the owner of The Link boutique) to style her, too.

Go for it, Ms Low. Do us proud.

Dr Woffles Wu

[This letter made me feel happy for Ris Low.  It made me think about what this opportunity means to her. We are not all born beautiful, and we don't all have the same skills and abilities. This is perhaps a chance of a lifetime for her. Let's not rain on her parade. I hope she has a good time at the final show.]

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

S'pore not the only dragon that scores well in public policy

Sep 16, 2009

IN HIS commentary last Wednesday ("The Republic of Common Sense"), Professor Kishore Mahbubani compared the PUB's 99.9 per cent water delivery record with the problem of irregular maintenance of hundreds of miles of water pipes in the United States to illustrate Singapore's superior public policies.

But the US is so much bigger with so many more pipes to maintain. The US infrastructure is also much older. The recent stink about the Pasir Ris coast being contaminated by old, leaking sewerage pipes shows just how difficult it is to tackle the problem of aged infrastructure.

Singapore may often be cited as one of the models of development, but that does not mean Singapore is unique in and of its own in its rapid development. What is often forgotten is that Singapore is merely one of four East Asian dragons and much of the success of our policies and institutions is rooted in who we are - East Asians.

It would be good indeed if the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, which Prof Mahbubani heads, can help raise the level of reflection and questioning in Singapore.

Ng Kok Lim

[So by raising the level of reflection and questioning, we would conclude that the success of our policies and institutions is because we are East Asians? So Hong Kong, Taiwan & S. Korea being the other 4 dragons also have good and sound public policies?

Then what about Thailand, Malaysia, Philippines, and the Indochina countries? They are East Asians too? Ng's letter is ironic evidence that there is a lack of reflection and questioning by Singaporeans, if his conclusion is based more on cultural/racial prejudice rather than well thought out arguments.

(edit: In other words, thinly veiled racism)

As for the Pasir Ris problem, Ng apparently makes no differentiation between water pipes and sewerage pipes. He may be taking Newater a little too literally. But not to sweep the problem under the carpet, at least the authorities recognise there is a problem and is acting to solve the problem, and there is a plan to resolve the problem. It is not unknown for other countries to deny there is a problem and let people swim in contaminated waters, or give up on the problem - no budget and other priorities, and make vague promises to solve the problem... which then drags on for decades without resolution. That's poor public policy.

There are some cities in the US that uses a tagline "The city that works" If any city deserves such a tag, it is Singapore.]