Thursday, February 18, 2010

Beware of 'too big to fail' situation

Feb 19, 2010

IN THE late 1990s, local banks consolidated and a dominant three emerged. The rationale then - to remain competitive both locally and abroad - was compelling, even when POSB merged with DBS.

In similar vein, our transport system pivots on a couple of major operators.

Singaporeans were reminded recently that most adverse developments in the past decade could not have been foreseen. So it stands to reason that our regulatory authorities may not be able to guarantee in future that mainstays of our economy are not buffeted by global downturns to the point of distress or even bankruptcy.

The Economic Strategies Committee suggested even more consolidation. However, given the vagaries of the global economy, is it wise to develop corporate behemoths that may eventually become too big to fail locally and require national resources to be rescued?

Errol Goodenough

[Thoughtful letter, but inadvertantly presumptuous. "Too big to fail" was applied to mega-MNCs, corporations with international reach, and some national corporations (Freddie Mac) that would have had a domino effect in bringing down other institutions. If our transport operators fail, some other operator will buy over the business for a dollar, along with the infrastructure and assets (rolling stock), and continue from there. We're not going to be stranded at the bus stop or train station. And the govt is not going to rescue them. In fact, one wonders about the need for 2 transit operators. For a compact city state like Singapore, one is enough. Good enough, even.]

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Good govt must allow political vibrancy

Feb 18, 2010
INCORRUPTIBILITY NOT ENOUGH

DR YIK Keng Yeong's letter ('...As long as PAP remains incorruptible', Feb 9) alluded to the negative ramifications of political competitiveness and the positive prognosis of firm and decisive leadership.

Political leadership dictates that a government's overriding mandate is the welfare of the nation and the people it governs. And a corrupted government almost certainly leads to a decline in the nation's welfare.

However, incorruptibility alone is not enough. A government can be incorruptible but not infallible, simply because no human being is.

[A government is not a single human being. It is many persons. Therefore it overcomes the fallibility issue with internal checks and balances so that no single person (except in a dictatorship or a monarchy) can make an egocentric decision without the inputs of the rest. That said, any government (or group) is susceptible to "groupthink", and political parties are susceptible to in-breeding, and attracting/selecting like-minded individuals. ]

Fallibility cannot be eliminated, but the risks associated with it can be mitigated. As no one can predict the future with certainty, a government can rely on only four types of wisdom: its own, the people's, that of other governments, and that of people in other nations.

A government that listens only to itself will not hear the people's needs. A government that listens only to itself and its people cannot make informed decisions internationally.
A government that does not listen to the people of other nations may not appreciate the destiny humanity crafts as it progresses.

[Here the writer starts to get philosophical and confuses the role of government and wishful thinking. Human Destiny? That is a debatable concept, and assumes a homogeniety that denies the diversity of the human experience (how's that for philosophy!). The role of government is simply to govern. But within the "simply to govern" is a whole lot of work to govern well. The US Republican party believes that government is a necessary evil and should be as small as possible and get out of the way of people as much as possible. Republican candidates therefore fight to get elected so that they can do as little as possible, apparently. Most governments believe that they are elected to govern and that means making decisions for the general wellbeing of the people, and not just exercising the will of the majority, but also protecting the rights of the minorities. Listening to the people of other nations assumes that these people speak with one voice, and also assumes that their one voice is reasonable. The reality is that the nations of the world seldom speak with one voice, and are seldom reasonable. But even if they were, subjecting ourselves to the will of the majority would be the definition of "tyranny of the majority".]

A government can fulfil the duties predicated by its mandate only if it is guided by all forms of wisdom, constructive or destructive, conventional or radical.


[Idealistic. Foolish. Contradictory. You can be conventional or radical. But not both at the same time. Whether conventional wisdom is right or radical innovation is right is a matter of context and situation. One cannot be guided by ALL kinds of wisdom ALL the time. Being wise is knowing when one approach is more applicable than another. Not being guided by ALL wisdom. That's just being non-discriminatory and a sign that you don't know what you are doing.]

The burden lies not in the correctness of the decision, but in the rightness on which the decision is based. Ultimately, the decision is a government's, but not before it has rigorously weighed the alternatives. It is only fair to the people that their government makes a decision that is exhaustively informed and conscientiously wise.

[The rightness of the decision is dependent on the context and situation of the people. All other philosophical consideration are just idealism.]

As such, differences - competition and opposition - should be actively engaged, if not sought, not for a government to make the right decision, but to allow it to make a decision that is right.
The only resistance to be eliminated is one that threatens a government's overriding mandate: the nation's welfare.

[What needs to be eliminated is extraneous considerations that muddies the water and confuses the situation, and prevents the proper identification of the critical issues to be addressed. Opposition for the sake of opposition does not propel good governance forward. In any case, if the over-riding mandate is the nation's welfare, then what was all that crap earlier about human destiny and international consultation? While not all decisions and choices are zero-sum game, the reason why we are not an ASEAN community with transnational government - like the European parliament which is a lame duck anyway - is because in a lot of matters, what benefits one nation is seen rightly or wrongly as being detrimental to another. While Malaysia is our closest neighbour and important trading partner, issues like water, airspace, air routes, fuel costs and other policies separate us. If we sought alignment with M'sian policies, would we have bumiputra policies, and be paying $5 for water?]

Ultimately, political leadership is a burden, not a reward. A government that upholds the nation's welfare will receive its people's loyalty.


A government that shoulders the nation's welfare, and survives the challenges of contrarians, will gain the world's admiration.

David Tan


[In terms of "contrarians" Singapore's model of democracy is problematic enough for the liberal democracies of the west. By their estimate, a country like us should have failed, with miserable people, poverty, and under-development due to our atrophied democracy. Instead, we are well-developed, with high levels of medical and healthcare, housing, financial and other industrial infrastructure with practically just a modicum or superficial democracy. Whereas countries with more robust and vibrant democracies like Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, and maybe even Thailand, are struggling or just emerging. So we have admirers in the world. Not unanimous admiration because we do not pander to the ideologues who want democracy for the sake of democracy rather than good governance for the sake of the people.]

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Singaporeans decide their destiny

Feb 8, 2010

I READ with consternation condescending comments by United States ambassador-designate to Singapore David Adelman on his plan to use 'public diplomacy' to promote political and press freedom ('Envoy-designate to Singapore faces panel', last Thursday).

These are matters for Singaporeans to decide. It is none of Mr Adelman's business to try and propagate the 'ambitions Americans have for democracy'. Singaporeans are accountable for our own destiny and he will be well served minding his country's own busines

The world does not need a United States that goes around teaching people how to live their lives, especially by a representative who has never worked outside his own country. The sky viewed from the bottom of a well looks clear blue.

Johnny Heng


---------

comments from on-line:

It would be a mistake to be lured into a state of mind of 'my country right or wrong'.It is short-sighted and ill-informed to appear to reject what is obvious. To many thinking Singaporeans, it is not so much that an American, an outsider, is attempting to poke its nose into our business.To many of us, what really matters is whether he makes sense, whether what he says has a RING OF TRUTH about it. And we all know, including the ruling party, that indeed this is the case.If it is so OBNOXIOUS to the govt, it could have very quickly sent a protest note or even straight awaydeclared the next US ambassador as persona non grata. And it has demonstrated in previous cases it is perfectly capable of this. BUT TAKE NOTE OF THE DEAFENING SILENCE FROM THE MFA.The govt proxy barking dogs are merely making up the impression that ordinary citizens are indignant about what the ambassador said on behalf of the govt because it is unable according to its 'internal' calculation, that it shouldn't.

[The "deafening silence" is called diplomacy. Adelman was in a job interview. His interviewers may well have been rabid democracy-exporters. Or believers in the god-given right of the US of A to bring civilisation to the heathen masses. In any case, he was asked, what would he do about this irascible nation much like you might be ask during a job interview if you would be willing to sacrifice a weekend or two for your work. Of course we all say yes. Unless you are incredibly truthful and courageous and don't really need the job.]

Recall what LKY said to Charlie Rose at a recent TV interview. LKYwas provoking the US to stay in the region buy painting a spectra of a looming Chinese BLUE navy. His remarks cause a widespread unhappiness in the PRC. His behaviour marked in out as a 'two headed snake'.Perhaps too that was the ulteriormotive behind all those massive billions of our reserves investments and losses in US banks and investment houses.The US message to LKY is: If you want us to stay around to staunch a perceived Chinese hegemony in the region, then you should be a little more like the American people whose belief and acquiescence the US govt needs to commit its forces and presence in this region.It's no longer LKY's usual 'It's my way or the highway' as far as this matter is concerned. Obama is not Bush. Democrats are not Republican. As an aside, the discerning reader of the ST will notice an unfriendly undertone in the articles of the ST journalist currently covering the US. This is a covert extension of LKY's less than welcoming stance towards Obama's presidency. The Obama bashing is more than a little obvious. Now, compare this to what the ST wrote during George W Bush's 8 years.

[Singapore knows which side the bread is buttered and doesn't engage in US-bashing. We don't practice brinksmanship or oneupmanship or any other kind of cheap ploys for domestic politics. Bash Obama? Most Singaporeans have little interest in news beyond our shores. Sure we like big business Republicans more than domestic-minded Democrats, but we can work with what's available.]

On a historical note, memories are short. If not for the US entering the war in WW2 and the atomic bomb, we would have remained a member of Japan's 'East Asia C-prosperity Sphere' and also not to mention Hitler's Nazi's fortune in Europe. The US is not a perfect nation, but it certainly has a lot the we can learn and adopt from it in the making of our nation. Over the last 40-50 years, we have seen both the pros and cons and strengths and weaknesses when there is only one party in charge. We are now stagnate at a plateau economic development-wise. The PAP has run out of ideas. The IR shows the desperation. Have you heard anything new beyond the IR on the way forward for Singapore?

[If you have any good ideas toss it out. But Singapore is pursuing many roads. Bio-tech, medical, pharmaceuticals, software, design, game development, aerospace. No big guns? No main engine of growth like petrochemical, manufacturing, or wafer-fab? Firstly, depending on just one main engine is highly risky. Second, the world doesn't work that way anymore. At this stage of our development, growth will slow down. Find a first world country with sustainable growth in 2 digits or even in the high single digit. There are none. China can grow so fast because its base is so small. The US financial was booming because it was based on high risk leverage. There's no such thing as get rich quick without high risk and for every one that rakes in the bucks, a hundred or a thousand others lose the shirt off their backs.]

The financial crisis clearly and absolutely shows up the consequence of the govt's inbreeding and monopoly of the political and economic processes, The continual blatant manipulation of the electoral system and process underscores the physical perils and mortal dangers to citizens and the nationhood of Singapore. Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. For the love of money is the root of all evils.

[The financial crisis is the making of poor financial regulation and greed from the USA, that bastion of capitalism, free economy, and democracy. To turn the financial crisis around and blame the PAP for it requires mental gymnastics and leaps in logic that clearly puts one in the delusional category.]

Posted by: commentator_sc at Mon Feb 08 13:01:07 SGT 2010

[I do not know what David Adelman stands for. He is described as a progressive Democrat and his electoral wins are clear and decisive. His answers at the hearing for his candidacy for ambassadorship is certainly newsworthy, if not worrying if he means it. But again, it is a "job interview" so one shouldn't read too much into it. Let his action speak for itself. Certainly, Singapore is not an enemy but a strong and strategic ally. It is not in the US interests to bully, undermine, or embarrass their allies. Certainly no one has a clear definition of "public democracy". As opposed to what, "private democracy"? So his replies at the hearing may be no more than diplomatic replies to ensure he secures the ambassadorship.]

Friday, February 5, 2010

More single seats may disadvantage PAP

Feb 6, 2010

I REFER to Thursday's letter by Dr Jason Wong, 'Having more single seats will help the PAP'. I feel his reasoning is somewhat myopic and he has made certain assumptions which may not be accurate, stemming from observations of polling results in Singapore in the past.

First, he mentioned that maintaining 'vulnerable' group representation constituencies (GRCs) such as Bishan-Toa Payoh and Tampines may be detrimental to the People's Action Party (PAP), as opposed to converting the 10 seats in these GRCs to single member constituencies (SMCs).

Even though in the next general election, Bishan-Toa Payoh GRC may be led by Mr Chiam See Tong (unanimously the strongest opposition figure based on his track record in Potong Pasir over the past 25 years), an opposition victory is unlikely. In 1997, led by the late Mr J.B. Jeyaretnam, the Workers' Party still lost in Cheng San GRC. Moreover, the opposition has not come close to winning Tampines GRC in the past 20 years, bearing in mind that the greatest opposition threat in the east was in Eunos GRC 22 years ago.

Second, Dr Wong seems to suggest the PAP may have a better chance of winning SMCs when this may not be the case as younger and less experienced PAP candidates may be pitted against opposition heavyweights who have worked the ground over the years. If the number of SMCs is expanded, these less experienced PAP candidates may no longer have the 'shield' of contesting a GRC led by a PAP heavyweight.

However, I agree with Dr Wong's suggestion to increase the number of SMCs as this will aid the ruling party in quashing criticism that many PAP newcomers become ministers without a proper 'fight'. More important, it will also address the age-old criticism of the GRC system being just an excuse to win more seats by the winning party, as a multiracial nation like Malaysia does not resort to GRCs to ensure that minority MPs are represented in Parliament.

Robin Chee

[Malaysia does not resort to GRCs to ensure minority representation. But is the M'sian system better? Their BN coalition of UMNO, MCA, Gerakan, MIC and other smaller parties leads not to a strong govt, but a weak compromise. The ethnic enclaves create pockets of opportunity where a minority candidate from any party has a chance, but leads inevitably to race-based politics that are hobbling the progress of the country when it is not tearing it apart.

To adopt the "M'sian solution" would mean creating race-based political parties, and entrenching the politics of race and all the disadvantages if not hazards of such an approach. Proposals to increase the number of SMCs should be welcomed, as well as reducing the size of GRCs. Originally, GRCs were just 3 members, but they eventually grew to 6-member super-GRCs. Such GRCs were steep obstacles for the opposition and raised suspicions about the PAP's intent and motives.

In the next election, we would probably see 14 SMCs, and about 10 GRCs of 4 wards each, and 6 GRCs of 5 wards each (Assuming 84 wards as per current). ]

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Having more single seats will help the PAP

Feb 4, 2010

I REFER to the opposition's interest in contesting at least two group representation constituencies (GRCs) in the next General Election. The People's Action Party (PAP) may wish to reconsider which of the constituencies should remain as GRCs while redrawing the rest as single-member constituencies (SMCs) for three reasons.

First, the opposition seems confident of winning the Tampines and Bishan- Toa Payoh GRCs. The opposition almost won the Eunos GRC in the 1988 General Election with 49.1 per cent of the votes. In subsequent general elections, the opposition garnered more than 40 per cent of the votes in a few GRCs. And judging from ground and online sentiments, a GRC victory or two for the opposition is a strong possibility.

Second, such a loss may mean losing 10 seats in Parliament altogether. If, however, the 10 constituencies are redrawn as SMCs, the ruling party may still keep more than half the SMCs.

Third, many citizens are unhappy that some MPs entered Parliament by piggybacking on party heavyweights through the GRC format.

The PAP should consider having more SMCs so that more of their fresh candidates can prove their worth by winning a seat on their own steam.

How many SMCs? At least half of the total parliamentary seats.

Dr Jason Wong

[Idealist. The proposed amendments to the parliamentary elections would create more SMCs and smaller GRCs. But half of all seats as SMCs? The doctor is dreaming.]

Sunday, January 31, 2010

'Allah' a Muslim term to the ordinary man

Jan 31, 2010
YOUR LETTERS

I thank Mr Janadas Devan for highlighting the excellent etymology of the word 'Allah' ('What's in a name?') last Sunday.

The Cobuild Series English Dictionary defines 'Allah' as 'the name of God in Islam', while The Reader's Digest-Oxford Complete Wordfinder refers to it as 'the name of God among Arabs and Muslims'.

The dictionary definitions would be the understanding of the word for the ordinary Ali in Bedok, Ah Lee in Beijing and Ally in Brooklyn.

The expression 'By Allah...' is commonly ascribed to Muslims everywhere. Does one connect the refrain to non-Muslims?

After the Sept11, 2001 terrorist attacks in New York, Muslim leaders tirelessly reminded their flock not to blindly imitate the practices of their fellow Muslims in the Middle East.

Contextualisation, they emphasised, was critical. What may be suitable in the Arab countries may not be practical in the local environment.

The biggest concern must be at the grassroots level, with the strength of social fabric being the key indicator.

If the unity quotient has risen, then the status quo can and should remain.

But if it has plunged over time and become more porous and fragile, etymology is the last thing that policymakers will consider when undertaking a policy review.

Mohamad Rosle Ahmad

[I appreciate that this letter is well-written and puts the point of the writer across very well: that etymology aside, the question is what is the ordinary person's understanding of the term.

In other words, the common understanding of the phrase, at least in this part of the world is that "Allah" is commonly understood as to mean exclusively the Islamic God. And as to the point that even the Arabs do not claim exclusivity of the term, the writer counters that with the exhortation not to slavishly imitate the Arabs in the wake of 911, the reference to Arab practices smacks of hypocrisy: Don't follow the Arabs when it doesn't suit us, and follow when it suits us.

Here then are the problems with the claim of exclusivity of the term. Firstly "this part of the world" seems to mean only West M'sia and maybe Singapore. As Singapore is unlikely to officially support such an exclusivity, the only country, and even then only half a country (by land area if not by population) is M'sia and only W. M'sia. Indonesia and East M'sia does not have a problem. And even in W. M'sia it is not unanimous that all Islamic leaders are on the side of the claims of exclusivity. The genesis of this controversy seems to be politically motivated, and a gambit by UMNO to be seen as more "Islamic" than PAS. This is debatable and like the etymology of the word "Allah" may be irrelevant as the writer claims.

However, the etymology of the word may not be as irrelevant as the writer claims. There is two approach to this issue. One, make the claim to customary use and understanding and refuse to consider new facts (etymology) and learn new things, and claim that the status quo should be left well and good alone.

Or Two, open one's mind to new facts, consider these facts, argue about the facts and then decide the best way forward. A closed mind and defending the status quo by refusing to consider facts and history is a sign of a siege mentality.

In any case, the etymology of the word is not simply a matter of language evolution and word usage. It also traces the Abrahamic faiths, and the simple matter is that as Judaism-Christianity-Islam share the same origins, then the 3 faiths reference the same God, then how true or how correct is the position that the same God cannot be called by the same name?

The PAS leader took this position which is a learned position based on a correct understanding of the origins of Abrahamic faiths. The M'sian Minister's position is based at best on customary understanding and at worst on political motivation.

The position taken by PAS (which surprisingly is more moderate and backed by sound scholarly understanding) is that unless and until "Allah" is used to confuse, proselytise, or promote apostasy, Christians have as much right to use it as Muslims.

Marina Mahathir commented that Muslims are not so stupid or weak-minded as to walk into a church, see the cross above an altar, the pews, and a priest and the moment someone says "Allah", think that they are in a mosque.

And yes, the writer is correct to say that etymology or any kind of logic is the last thing politicians will consider in their policy review. Political mileage and political points will be their only consideration.

And that is sad, and wrong and will sow the seeds of future problems.]

Friday, January 29, 2010

Taxpayers should not fund the policing of casinos

Jan 30, 2010

I REFER to Thursday's report, 'Special training for police unit fighting casino crime'.

I am puzzled as to why the Singapore Police Force is setting up a unit, funded by taxpayers, to investigate crimes and fraudulent gambling in the casinos in the integrated resorts. The police should preserve law and order, and enforce the property rights of common citizens. Taxpayers' money is used to fund the force because all citizens stand to benefit from law, order and property rights.

A police force in any country is funded by taxpayers' money because the public at large stands to gain more than any individual.

However, the only beneficiaries from the prevention of fraud in casinos are the casino operators, and there are no visible spillover benefits to general law enforcement from police officers being trained to detect fraudsters in casinos, because the casinos are a specialised setting.

If the police did not have a casino crime unit, the only losers would be the casinos themselves, and being profit-seeking organisations, they would naturally pay for detection of such fraud, such as by training their own investigators to detect fraudulent gambling.

In other words, enforcement of honest behaviour in casinos is not a public good, from an economic point of view, and the casinos can pay for it because they are the only ones who stand to gain from preventing fraud. Public funds are being used unfairly to pay for the protection of private interests of the profit-seeking casinos. This injustice is exacerbated by the fact that casinos typically earn outrageous profits, and it is only right that they pay to protect their own interests.

Tan Jiaqi

[Good argument, but short-sighted/narrow-minded. If the police did not develop the expertise, then they would be fully reliant on the casino operators' security team's expertise. Then it is entirely possible that organised crime can take over, and use the casino operations as a front to move money about and the police would be none the wiser.

But by developing their own expertise the police prevents (or hopes to prevent) organised fraud or money laundering schemes. Casinos are potential centres for illegal activities, and it is right that the police focus their attention there.

If not, Singapore may gain a bad reputation for being soft or unable to detect fraud. This tarnishes our overall image. And while the casinos make huge profits, Singapore gains from the huge tax on Casino takings. Therefore Singapore has a responsibility to ensure that this "whale" is properly cared for. The Casino is a resource and an asset and as such requires care and maintenance. Petroluem Refinery is also a commercial and profit oriented business, but the police would also be concerned with the safety and security of the business. The only difference is that the potential danger to the public is perhaps more obvious and physical in the case of oil refinery. BUT, one can easily argue that since these are all on offshore islands anyway, they do not pose a direct threat to citizens. But again, that would be a shortsighted, narrow-minded perspective.]